IP Library Granted Patent US 7,353,202
Granted Patent B2
US 7,353,202 · App. 09/814,547 · Granted Apr 1, 2008

System for and method of risk minimization and enhanced returns in an intellectual capital based venture investment

View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 7,353,202
App. No.
09/814,547
Granted
Apr 1, 2008
Kind
B2
Abstract

The disclosure relates to an investment risk minimization system involving a venture capital investor and a venture needing investment from the venture capital investor. In such a system, an exemplary method can include providing an investment to a venture having an intellectual asset, and receiving a security interest in the intellectual asset. The security interest secures an ownership right upon failure by the venture to meet established parameters. Further, if the venture receiving the investment fails to meet the established parameters, the method includes obtaining an ownership interest in the intellectual asset, valuing the intellectual asset, and transferring the intellectual asset to a charitable organization.

Claims (31)

1. In an investment risk minimization system involving a venture capital investor and a venture needing investment from the venture capital investor, a method performed in the following sequence comprising:

identifying a venture having an intellectual asset;

determining a value of the intellectual asset held by the venture;

establishing an amount of the investment at least partially based on the value of the intellectual asset;

determining for the venture minimum performance conditions needed for the investment to be recouped over a predetermined period of time, wherein the minimum performance conditions comprise at least one of a return on investment goal, an earnings goal, a market penetration goal, a gross sales goal or a combination thereof;

providing the investment to the venture having the intellectual asset;

receiving a security interest in the intellectual asset, the security interest securing an ownership right to the intellectual asset upon failure by the venture to meet minimum performance conditions;

obtaining ownership in the intellectual asset if the venture receiving the investment fails to meet the minimum performance conditions;

determining whether the intellectual asset has donation value based on predetermined considerations, wherein the intellectual asset will be determined to have donation value if it is determined that (i) there is a likely future market for the intellectual asset, (ii) there is a likelihood that other ventures can use the intellectual asset, or (iii) there is a likelihood that other ventures can obtain competitive protection by restricting access to the intellectual asset;

determining that the intellectual asset has donation value and should be donated to a charitable organization;

determining an appraised fair value for the intellectual asset based on predetermined factors, wherein the factors comprise at least one of cost of selling the intellectual asset within a reasonable period of time, sales of comparable intellectual assets, cost of reproduction of the intellectual asset, opinion appraisals of the intellectual asset, and any combination thereof;

calculating a tax deduction obtained from transferring of the intellectual asset to the charitable organization; and

transferring the intellectual asset to the charitable organization at the appraised fair value of the intellectual asset.

2. The method of claim 1 , wherein the obtaining further comprises obtaining consent from the venture to own the intellectual asset in satisfaction of the failed investment.

3. The method of claim 1 , wherein the transferring further comprises identifying a permissible charitable organization to receive the intellectual asset.

4. The method of claim 1 , wherein the determining a value of the intellectual asset comprises having the intellectual asset appraised by a qualified appraiser.

5. The method of claim 1 , wherein the providing the investment to the venture comprises investing in a separate intellectual capital holding company, and wherein the intellectual capital holding company receives the security interest in the intellectual asset of the venture.

6. The method of claim 1 , wherein the determining a value of the intellectual asset comprises determining the fair market value of the intellectual asset.

7. In an investment risk minimization system involving a venture capital investor and a venture needing investment from the venture capital investor, a method performed in the following sequence comprising:

identifying a venture having an intellectual asset;

determining a value of the intellectual asset held by the venture;

establishing an amount of the investment at least partially based on the value of the intellectual asset;

determining for the venture minimum performance conditions needed for the investment to be recouped over a predetermined period of time, wherein the minimum performance conditions comprise at least one of a return on investment goal, an earnings goal, a market penetration goal, a gross sales goal or a combination thereof;

providing the investment to the venture having the intellectual asset;

receiving a security interest in the intellectual asset, the security interest securing an ownership right to the intellectual asset upon failure by the venture to meet minimum performance conditions;

obtaining ownership in the intellectual asset if the venture receiving the investment fails to meet the minimum performance conditions;

determining whether the intellectual asset has donation value based on predetermined considerations, wherein the factors for determining whether an intellectual asset has donation value comprise at least one of: (i) whether there is a likely future market for the intellectual asset, (ii) whether there is a likelihood that other ventures can use the intellectual asset, or (iii) whether there is a likelihood that other ventures can obtain competitive protection by restricting access to the intellectual asset;

determining that the intellectual asset has donation value and should be donated to a charitable organization;

calculating a tax deduction obtained from transferring of the intellectual asset to the charitable organization; and

transferring the intellectual asset to the charitable organization at the appraised fair value of the intellectual asset.

8. The an investment risk minimization system of claim 7 , further comprising determining an appraised fair value for the intellectual asset based on predetermined factors, wherein the factors comprise at least one of cost of selling the intellectual asset within a reasonable period of time, sales of comparable intellectual assets, cost of reproduction of the intellectual asset, opinion appraisals of the intellectual asset, and any combination thereof.

Assignments (3)
TERMINATION AND RELEASE OF SECURITY INTEREST IN INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Recorded Mar 21, 2022
From: OLD NATIONAL BANK
To: OCEAN TOMO, LLC
Reel/Frame 059454/0609 →
SECURITY AGREEMENT Recorded Jan 10, 2011
From: OCEAN TOMO, LLC
To: FIRST MIDWEST BANK
Reel/Frame 025675/0432 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded May 26, 2006
From: MALACKOWSKI, JAMES E.
To: OCEAN TOMO, LLC
Reel/Frame 017703/0164 →