IP Library Granted Patent US 7,136,794
Granted Patent B1
US 7,136,794 · App. 10/011,428 · Granted Nov 14, 2006

Method and apparatus for estimating values for condition indicators

Assignee: Simmonds Precision Products, Inc.
View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 7,136,794
App. No.
10/011,428
Granted
Nov 14, 2006
Kind
B1
Abstract

Disclosed are techniques used in connection with determining a health indicator (HI) of a component, such as that of an aircraft component. The HI is determined using condition indicators (CIs) which parameterize characteristics about a component minimizing possibility of a false alarm. Different algorithms are disclosed which may be used in determining one or more CIs. The HI may be determined using a normalized CI value. Techniques are also described in connection with selecting particular CIs that provide for maximizing separation between HI classifications. Given a particular HI at a point in time for a component, techniques are described for predicting a future state or health of the component using the Kalmán filter. Techniques are described for estimating data values as an alternative to performing data acquisitions, as may be used when there is no pre-existing data.

Claims (117)

1. A computer-implemented method for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a gear pair comprising:

modeling said gear pair as a damped spring model having a contact line between said gears;

determining a force, P, at a point of contact along said contact line causing linear and torsional response to each of said two gears in said gear pair;

determining a relative movement, d, of said gear pair, in accordance with said force, P, as a sum of four responses and a contact deflection, said relative movement d representing a gear model having two degrees of freedom, said contact deflection being due to a contact stiffness of a contact patch where two gears of said gear pair come into contact, and a linear damping coefficient of the contact patch; and

using said relative movement, d, in determining said conditional indicator value for transmission error associated with said gear pair.

2. The method of claim 1 , further comprising:

varying parameter values in accordance with simulating different fault conditions; and

determining mean and threshold values for said different fault conditions.

3. A method executed in a computer system for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a bearing comprising:

modeling said bearing with a bearing model using a plurality of parameters including a bearing frequency ratio, a periodic impulse, an intensity of an impulse, and a decay of a unit impulse, wherein said bearing model is used to model at least one condition associated with said bearing, wherein said periodic impulse is determined in accordance with said bearing frequency ratio, said periodic impulse representing a modeled impulse train corresponding to said bearing rolling for a simulation time period, said intensity of an impulse on a bearing surface being determined as a function of an angle relative to a bearing fault;

modeling a movement of said bearing using said bearing model; and

determining a conditional indicator value associated with said bearing in accordance with said movement.

4. The method of claim 3 , wherein said bearing frequency ratio corresponds to one of: an inner race frequency and an outer bearing race frequency.

5. The method of claim 3 , further comprising:

varying parameter values in determining conditional indicator values associated with different health classifications of said bearing.

6. The method of claim 5 , further comprising:

estimating values associated with a gear noise;

estimating values associated with a bearing noise; and

estimating a condition indicator of a gear and bearing noise as a combined signal using said values associated with said gear noise and said bearing noise.

7. A method executed in a computer system for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a bearing comprising:

determining a bearing frequency ratio for said bearing;

determining a periodic impulse in accordance with said bearing frequency ratio;

determining an intensity of an impulse on a bearing surface as a function of an angle relative to a bearing fault;

determining a decay of a unit impulse;

determining a movement of said bearing;

determining a conditional indicator value associated with said bearing in accordance with said movement;

varying parameter values in determining conditional indicator values associated with different health classifications of said bearing;

estimating values associated with a gear noise;

estimating values associated with a bearing noise;

estimating a condition indicator of a gear and bearing noise as a combined signal using said values associated with said gear noise and said bearing noise; and

determining said combined signal s(t) as:

s ( t )=[ d ( t ) f ( t ) q ( t ) a ( t )]* e ( t )* h ( t )

where:

h(t) is a frequency response of a gear case;

d(t) is a signal associated with gear and shaft transmission error;

f(t) is a bearing frequency ratio;

q(t) is an amplitude at a particular time t,

a(t) is a cosine for one of an inner and outer race condition at a location theta at which an impulse is applied to said bearing; and

e(t) is a decay rate of unit impulse.

8. The method of claim 7 , wherein h(t) is determined using one of: a linear predictive coding (LPC) technique and modal hammer analysis.

9. The method of claim 7 , further comprising:

determining a frequency spectrum of signals of s(t) as S(f) in the frequency domain by forming:

S ( f )=[ D ( f )* F ( f )* Q ( f )* A ( f )] E ( f ) H ( f )

in the frequency domain.

10. A computer readable medium for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a gear pair comprising machine executable code stored thereon causing a computer to perform:

modeling said gear pair as a damped spring model having a contact line between said gears;

determining a force, P, at a point of contact along said contact line causing linear and torsional response to each of said two gears in said gear pair;

determining a relative movement, d, of said gear pair, in accordance with said force, P, as a sum of four responses and a contact deflection, said relative movement d representing a gear model having two degrees of freedom, said contact deflection being due to a contact stiffness of a contact patch where two gears of said gear pair come into contact, and a linear damping coefficient of the contact patch; and

using said relative movement, d, in determining said conditional indicator value for transmission error associated with said gear pair.

11. The computer readable medium of claim 10 , further comprising machine executable code stored thereon for:

varying parameter values in accordance with simulating different fault conditions; and

determining mean and threshold values for said different fault conditions.

12. A computer readable medium for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a bearing comprising machine executable code stored thereon causing a computer to perform:

modeling said bearing with a bearing model using a plurality of parameters including a bearing frequency ratio, a periodic impulse, an intensity of an impulse, and a decay of a unit impulse, wherein said bearing model is used to model at least one condition associated with said bearing, wherein said periodic impulse is determined in accordance with said bearing frequency ratio, said periodic impulse representing a modeled impulse train corresponding to said bearing rolling for a simulation time period, said intensity of an impulse on a bearing surface being determined as a function of an angle relative to a bearing fault;

modeling a movement of said bearing using said bearing model; and

determining a conditional indicator value associated with said bearing in accordance with said movement.

13. The computer readable medium of claim 12 , wherein said bearing frequency ratio corresponds to one of: an inner race frequency and an outer bearing race frequency.

14. The computer readable medium of claim 12 , further comprising machine executable code stored thereon for:

varying parameter values in determining conditional indicator values associated with different health classifications of said bearing.

15. The computer readable medium of claim 14 , further comprising machine executable code stored thereon for:

estimating values associated with a gear noise;

estimating values associated with a bearing noise; and

estimating a condition indicator of a gear and bearing noise as a combined signal using said values associated with said gear noise and said bearing noise.

16. A computer readable medium for estimating a conditional indicator value associated with a bearing comprising machine executable code stored thereon causing a computer to perform:

determining a bearing frequency ratio for said bearing;

determining a periodic impulse in accordance with said bearing frequency ratio;

determining an intensity of an impulse on a bearing surface as a function of an angle relative to a bearing fault;

determining a decay of a unit impulse;

determining a movement of said bearing;

determining a conditional indicator value associated with said bearing in accordance with said movement;

varying parameter values in determining conditional indicator values associated with different health classifications of said bearing;

estimating values associated with a gear noise;

estimating values associated with a bearing noise;

estimating a condition indicator of a gear and bearing noise as a combined signal using said values associated with said gear noise and said bearing noise; and

determining said combined signal s(t) as:

s ( t )=[ d ( t ) f ( t ) q ( t ) a ( t )]* e ( t )* h ( t )

where:

h(t) is a frequency response of a gear case;

d(t) is a signal associated with gear and shaft transmission error;

f(t) is a bearing frequency ratio;

q(t) is an amplitude at a particular time t,

a(t) is a cosine for one of an inner and outer race condition at a location theta at which an impulse is applied to said bearing; and

e(t) is a decay rate of unit impulse.

17. The computer readable medium of claim 16 , wherein h(t) is determined using one of: a linear predictive coding technique and modal hammer analysis.

18. The computer readable medium of claim 16 , further comprising machine executable code stored thereon for:

determining a frequency spectrum of signals of s(t) as S(f) in the frequency domain represented as

S ( f )=[ D ( f )* F ( f )* Q ( f )* A ( f )] E ( f ) H ( f )

in the frequency domain.

19. The method of claim 1 , wherein a first of said four responses utilizes a linear damping coefficient of a pinion, a second of said four responses utilizes an angular damping coefficient of the pinion, a third of said four responses utilizes a linear damping coefficient of a wheel, and a fourth of said four responses utilizes an angular damping coefficient of the wheel.

20. The method of claim 1 , wherein P is an estimated value represented as

P =(1 /kp*rp )+(1 /sp )+(1 /sw )+(1 /kwrw ), and wherein

kp is the angular effective stiffness of a pinion,

rp is a radius of the pinion,

sp is a linear stiffness of the pinion,

sw is a linear stiffness of a wheel,

kw is an angular effective stiffness of the wheel, and

rw is a radius of the wheel.

21. The method of claim 2 , further comprising:

using one or more manufacturer supplied data values to determine said parameter values corresponding to a modeled healthy state of said gear pair; and

modifying said one or more parameter values to determine additional parameter values corresponding to one or more of said different fault conditions.

22. The method of claim 21 , wherein one of said fault conditions corresponds to simulated alarm level having one or more of said parameter values estimated as a percentage of a manufacturer supplied value corresponding to a healthy state.

23. The computer readable medium of claim 10 , wherein a first of said four responses utilizes a linear damping coefficient of a pinion, a second of said four responses utilizes an angular damping coefficient of the pinion, a third of said four responses utilizes a linear damping coefficient of a wheel, and a fourth of said four responses utilizes an angular damping coefficient of the wheel.

24. The computer readable medium of claim 10 , wherein P is an estimated value represented as P=(1/kp*rp)+(1/sp)+(1/sw)+(1/kwrw), and wherein

kp is the angular effective stiffness of a pinion,

rp is a radius of the pinion,

sp is a linear stiffness of the pinion,

sw is a linear stiffness of a wheel,

kw is an angular effective stiffness of the wheel, and

rw is a radius of the wheel.

25. The computer readable medium of claim 11 , further comprising executable code stored thereon for:

using one or more manufacturer supplied data values to determine said parameter values corresponding to a modeled healthy state of said gear pair; and

modifying said one or more parameter values to determine additional parameter values corresponding to one or more of said different fault conditions.

26. The computer readable medium of claim 25 , wherein one of said fault conditions corresponds to simulated alarm level having one or more of said parameter values estimated as a percentage of a manufacturer supplied value corresponding to a healthy state.

27. The method of claim 3 , wherein said impulse train has a period dependent on a location of a fault.

28. The computer readable medium of claim 12 , wherein said impulse train has a period dependent on a location of a fault.

29. The method of claim 3 , wherein said at least one condition includes a fault condition associated with said bearing.

30. The computer readable medium of claim 12 , wherein said at least one condition includes a fault condition associated with said bearing.

Assignments (4)
CONFIRMATORY LICENSE Recorded Mar 29, 2013
From: SIMMONDS PRECISION PRODUCTS, INC.
To: DEPARTMENT OF THE NAVY, OFFICE OF COUNSEL
Reel/Frame 030128/0517 →
CONFIRMATORY LICENSE Recorded Mar 27, 2013
From: SIMMONDS PRECISION PRODUCTS, INC.
To: NAVAL AIR SYSTEMS COMMAND
Reel/Frame 030101/0769 →
CORRECTIVE COVERSHEET TO CORRECT ADDRESS OF RECEIVING PARTY ON ASSIGNMENT PREVIOUSLY RECORDED ON REEL 012369, FRAME 0534. Recorded Feb 19, 2004
From: BECHHOEFER, ERIC ROBERT
To: SIMMONDS PRECISION PRODUCTS, INC.
Reel/Frame 014971/0221 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Dec 4, 2001
From: BECHHOEFER, ERIC ROBERT
To: SIMMONDS PREICISION PRODUCTS, INC.
Reel/Frame 012369/0534 →
Continuity (1)
Provisional Application 6029333100 · May 24, 2001