Method and apparatus for providing talk permit notification for a PTT call
Various embodiments are described to provide push to talk (PTT) talk permit notification (TPN) with less average delay, given a desired rate of falsing, than prior art systems can achieve. A first communication system device (e.g., 101, 121, or 161 ) determines ( 504 ) whether one or more conditions are present for a PTT call that decrease the likelihood of successfully establishing the call. If ( 506 ) one or more conditions are present or a querying delay is expected to be less than an acceptable delay amount, the first device queries ( 508 ) a second communication system device (e.g., 121, 161, 122, or 102 ) for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the call before providing the TPN. Otherwise, the first device provides ( 512 ) the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed with the TPN from the second device.
1 . A method for providing talk permit notification (TPN) for a push to talk (PTT) call, the method comprising:
determining, by a first communication system device, whether at least one condition is present for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call;
if the at least one condition is present for the PTT call or a querying delay is expected to be less than an acceptable delay amount, querying a second communication system device for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call before providing the TPN; and
if the at least one condition is not present for the PTT call, providing the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed with the TPN from the second communication system device.
2 . The method of claim 1 , wherein the at least one condition for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call is at least one condition from the group consisting of
a condition where the PTT call is a private call,
a condition where the PTT call is a group call for which all the group members must be available to establish the call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call recently dropped due to RF loss,
a condition where an RF environment of a PTT target of the PTT call has recently been poor,
a condition where a serving cell of a PTT target of the PTT call effectively has no resources,
a condition where no signaling has recently occurred with a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked voice mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked e-mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent short message service message,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent PTT talk burst, and
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has a low battery.
3 . The method of claim 1 , further comprising
receiving from the second communication system device an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call.
4 . The method of claim 3 , wherein the indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call comprises an indication that at least one condition is present from the group consisting of
a condition where an RF environment of a PTT target of the PTT call has not recently been poor,
a condition where presence signaling has recently occurred with a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where a radio access network (RAN) of a PTT target of the PTT call has resources to support the PTT call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has registered and is not busy,
a condition where a page response has been received from a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where a reverse short data burst has been received from a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where acknowledgment signaling has been received from a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where signaling has been received from a PTT target on a traffic channel assigned for the PTT call.
5 . The method of claim 1 , wherein the first communication system device comprises a PTT server, wherein the second communication system device comprises a device from the group consisting of a PTT target and a radio access network (RAN) serving the PTT target, and wherein providing the TPN comprises indicating to user equipment (UE) to provide the TPN.
6 . The method of claim 5 , wherein querying the second communication system device for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call comprises soliciting a page response or reverse short data burst from the PTT target and
wherein the method further comprises not soliciting a page response or reverse short data burst from the PTT target if the at least one condition is not present for the PTT call.
7 . The method of claim 1 , wherein the first communication system device comprises user equipment (UE).
8 . The method of claim 7 , further comprising
receiving, by the UE prior to initiating the PTT call, an indication that the UE may provide TPNs without waiting for indications to proceed with the TPNs from the second communication system device.
9 . The method of claim 8 , wherein receiving the indication that the UE may provide TPNs without waiting for indications to proceed with the TPNs comprises
receiving an indication that the UE may provide TPNs without waiting for indications to proceed with the TPNs when at least one autonomous TPN condition is present.
10 . The method of claim 9 , wherein the at least one autonomous TPN condition is a condition from the group consisting of:
a number of PTT targets of the PTT call is greater than a threshold,
an amount of time since communication was received from a PTT target of the PTT call is less than a threshold,
a PTT target of the PTT call is a member of a designated set of PTT targets,
a PTT target of the PTT call has certain PTT attributes, and
a PTT target of the PTT call has certain presence attributes.
11 . The method of claim 7 , wherein querying the second communication system device for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call before providing the TPN comprises
indicating, by the UE in an INVITE message, that the UE is waiting to proceed with the TPN.
12 . The method of claim 7 , wherein providing the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed with the TPN from the second communication system device comprises waiting for an event from the group consisting of
receiving signaling in response to UE origination messaging for the PTT call,
receiving signaling in response to UE reverse short data burst signaling for the PTT call,
receiving channel assignment messaging for the PTT call, and
receiving signaling on a traffic channel assigned for the PTT call.
13 . User equipment (UE) for providing talk permit notification (TPN) for a push to talk (PTT) call, the UE comprising:
a transceiver; and
a processing unit, communicatively coupled to the transceiver,
adapted to determine whether at least one condition is present for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call,
adapted to query, via the transceiver, a communication system device for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call, before providing the TPN, if the at least one condition is present for the PTT call or a querying delay is expected to be less than an acceptable delay amount, and
adapted to provide the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed with the TPN from the second communication system device if the at least one condition is not present for the PTT call.
14 . The UE of claim 13 , wherein the at least one condition for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call is at least one condition from the group consisting of
a condition where the PTT call is a private call,
a condition where the PTT call is a group call for which all the group members must be available to establish the call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call recently dropped due to RF loss,
a condition where an RF environment of a PTT target of the PTT call has recently been poor,
a condition where a serving cell of a PTT target of the PTT call effectively has no resources,
a condition where no signaling has recently occurred with a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked voice mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked e-mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent short message service message,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent PTT talk burst, and
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has a low battery.
15 . The UE of claim 13 , wherein the processing unit is further
adapted to receive, via the transceiver prior to initiating the PTT call, an indication that the UE may provide TPNs without waiting for indications to proceed with the TPNs from the second communication system device.
16 . The UE of claim 13 , wherein the processing unit is further
adapted to query by indicating, in an INVITE message, that the UE is waiting to proceed with the TPN.
17 . The UE of claim 13 , wherein the processing unit is further adapted to provide the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed by waiting for an event from the group consisting of
receiving signaling in response to UE origination messaging for the PTT call,
receiving signaling in response to UE reverse short data burst signaling for the PTT call,
receiving channel assignment messaging for the PTT call, and
receiving signaling on a traffic channel assigned for the PTT call.
18 . Fixed network equipment (FNE) for providing talk permit notification (TPN) for a push to talk (PTT) call, the FNE comprising:
a network interface; and
a processing unit, communicatively coupled to the network interface,
adapted to determine whether at least one condition is present for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call,
adapted to query, via the network interface, a communication system device for an indication to proceed with a TPN for the PTT call, before providing the TPN, if the at least one condition is present for the PTT call or a querying delay is expected to be less than an acceptable delay amount, and
adapted to provide the TPN without waiting for an indication to proceed with the TPN from the second communication system device if the at least one condition is not present for the PTT call.
19 . The FNE of claim 18 , wherein the at least one condition for the PTT call that decreases the likelihood of successfully establishing the PTT call is at least one condition from the group consisting of
a condition where the PTT call is a private call,
a condition where the PTT call is a group call for which all the group members must be available to establish the call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call recently dropped due to RF loss,
a condition where an RF environment of a PTT target of the PTT call has recently been poor,
a condition where a serving cell of a PTT target of the PTT call effectively has no resources,
a condition where no signaling has recently occurred with a PTT target of the PTT call,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked voice mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has unchecked e-mail,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent short message service message,
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has not responded to a recent PTT talk burst, and
a condition where a PTT target of the PTT call has a low battery.
20 . The FNE of claim 18 , wherein the FNE comprises a PTT server, wherein the second communication system device comprises a device from the group consisting of a PTT target and a radio access network (RAN) serving the PTT target, and wherein the processing unit is further adapted to provide the TPN by indicating to user equipment (UE) to provide the TPN.