IP Library Granted Patent US 8,848,969
Granted Patent B2
US 8,848,969 · App. 13/245,316 · Granted Sep 30, 2014

Methods and apparatus for watermarking and distributing watermarked content

Inventors: Scott Ramsdell (Charlotte, NC); Craig Mahonchak (Broomfield, CO); Bryan Santangelo (Tulsa, OK)
Assignee: Time Warner Cable Enterprises LLC
G06T1/0021H04N1/32144
View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 8,848,969
App. No.
13/245,316
Granted
Sep 30, 2014
Kind
B2
Abstract

Methods and apparatus for generating and distributing watermarked content are described. Content to be distributed is sliced into a plurality of segments, e.g., short portions. Individual segments are subjected to watermarking with multiple watermarked versions of a segment being generated. Different watermarked versions of a segment communicate different information, e.g., one or more numbers. Sets of watermarked segments corresponding to a program are supplied to a content distribution device. Based on a session number or other information corresponding to the destination of the content, the content distribution device selects watermarked segments from the sets of segments to provide to the user. The combination of segments communicates, via the watermarks, a sequence of numbers used to identify the streamed content without requiring the distribution node to perform image processing to generate the watermarks. When the segments are communicated sequentially, the watermarks can be detected and the identifying numerical sequence extracted.

Claims (52)

1. A content distribution method, the method comprising:

receiving N watermarked versions of a first content segment, each of the N watermarked versions of the first content segment including a different watermark, N being a positive integer greater than 1;

receiving M watermarked versions of a second content segment, each of the M watermarked versions of the second content segment including a different watermark, M being a positive integer greater than 1;

receiving a session set up request from a customer premise device requesting content, said session set up request being a request for content;

generating a multi-bit session identifier in response to said session set up request;

generating a playlist of watermarked content segments corresponding to the requested content as a function of said multi-bit session identifier, said watermarked content segments in said playlist communicating at least said multi-bit session identifier; and

operating a video on demand server to generate a sequence of watermarked content segments in accordance with said playlist, said sequence of watermarked content segments including one of said N watermarked versions of the first content segment and one of said M watermarked versions of the second content segment, the sequence of watermarked content segments communicating said multi-bit session identifier with the requested content.

2. The method of claim 1 ,

wherein said playlist is a list of segments which are to be sequentially transmitted in accordance with the playlist to said customer premise device to provide the requested content; and

wherein said first and second content segments correspond to a movie or television program.

3. The method of claim 1 , wherein said watermarks correspond to numerical values, said sequence of watermarked content segments communicating a sequence of numerical values communicated by the watermarks included in the watermarked content segments included in said sequence of watermarked content segments.

4. The method of claim 1 , further comprising:

storing in a record the session identifier corresponding to said request for content along with billing account number information.

5. The method of claim 4 , wherein said record is a record in a log generated by a video server which supplied content in response to on-demand video content requests, said log including records corresponding to multiple different sessions, different records including different multi-bit session identifiers.

6. The method of claim 1 , wherein said step of generating a playlist of watermarked content segments includes:

selecting at least some of said watermarked segments from a set of differently watermarked versions of an individual segment as a function of time, said segments in the playlist communicating time information in addition to said multi-bit session identifier.

7. The method of claim 6 , wherein the method includes:

selecting for inclusion in said playlist at least one watermarked segment from said corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment as a function of a date.

8. The method of claim 6 , wherein the method includes:

selecting for inclusion in said playlist at least one watermarked segment from said corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment as a function of a geographic region to which said sequence of content segments is being provided.

9. The method of claim 6 , wherein the method includes:

selecting for inclusion in said playlist at least one watermarked segment from said corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment as a function of an identifier corresponding to a set top box or user to which the request for content corresponds.

10. The method of claim 6 , wherein the method includes:

selecting for inclusion in said playlist at least one watermarked segment from said corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment as a function of an address of a device from which said request for content was received.

11. The method of claim 6 , wherein the method includes:

selecting for inclusion in said playlist at least one watermarked segment from a corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment based on at least one of: i) a time; ii) a geographic region to which said sequence of content segments is being provided; iii) an identifier corresponding to a set top box or user to which the request for content corresponds; iv) a session identifier corresponding to a communications session in which said sequence of content segments is communicated; or v) an identifier corresponding to a regional server distributing said sequence of content segments.

12. The method of claim 1 , wherein said step of generating a playlist is performed by a first device which is a different device from said video on demand server, the method further comprising:

communicating said generated playlist from the first device to said video on demand server.

13. The method of claim 12 , wherein said generating and transmitting steps are performed by a headend of a content distribution system which includes said first device and said video on demand server, the headend receiving said N watermarked versions of the first content segment and said M watermarked versions of the second content segment from another network device.

14. The method of claim 13 , wherein said another network device is a content watermarking and distribution device coupled to a plurality of regional content distribution systems, the method further comprising operating said content watermarking and distribution device to:

receive content from a content supplier;

slice the received content into a plurality of segments, said plurality of segments including said first content segment and said second content segment;

perform a watermarking operation on said first content segment to generate said N watermarked versions of said first content segment; and

perform a watermarking operation on said second content segment to generate said M watermarked versions of said second content segment.

15. The method of claim 14 , wherein said another network device is a package media gateway, the method further comprising:

operating said package media gateway to supply differently watermarked sets of said first and second content segments to different regional content distribution systems.

16. A content distribution system, comprising:

a video on demand server with access to N watermarked versions of a first content segment, each of the N watermarked versions of the first content segment including a different watermark, N being a positive integer greater than 1, and for receiving M watermarked versions of a second content segment, each of the M watermarked versions of the second content segment including a different watermark, M being a positive integer greater than 1;

an application server configured to:

receive a session set up request from a customer premise device requesting content, said session set up request being a request for content;

generate a multi-bit session identifier in response to said session set up request;

generate a playlist of watermarked content segments corresponding to the requested content as a function of said multi-bit session identifier said watermarked content segments in said playlist communicating at least said multi-bit session identifier;

supply said playlist to said video on demand server;

and

wherein said application server is further configured to generate a sequence of watermarked content segments in accordance with said playlist, said sequence of watermarked content segments including one of said N watermarked versions of the first content segment and one of said M watermarked versions of the second content segment, the sequence of watermarked content segments communicating said multi-bit session identifier.

17. The content distribution system of claim 16 , wherein said watermarks correspond to numerical values, said sequence of watermarked content segments communicating a sequence of numerical values communicated by the watermarks indicating a time in addition to said multi-bit session identifier.

18. The content distribution system of claim 17 , further comprising:

memory for storing a record mapping said session identifier to an identifier of a user device and an identifier of the content which was streamed.

19. The content distribution system of claim 16 , wherein said sequence of watermarked content segments communicates a plurality of at least X watermarked segments, X being a positive integer greater than 7; and

wherein said content distribution apparatus further comprises:

means for selecting each individual one of said X watermarked segments from a set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment being selected.

20. The content distribution system of claim 19 , wherein said application server is configured to select at least one watermarked segment from a corresponding set of differently watermarked versions of said individual segment as a function of a geographic region to which said sequence of content segments is being provided.

Assignments (8)
SECURITY INTEREST Recorded Jul 25, 2018
From: BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS OPERATING, LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INTERNET LLC
To: WELLS FARGO TRUST COMPANY, N.A.
Reel/Frame 046630/0193 →
SECURITY INTEREST Recorded Jul 17, 2018
From: ADCAST NORTH CAROLINA CABLE ADVERTISING, LLC; ALABANZA LLC; AMERICA'S JOB EXCHANGE LLC; COAXIAL COMMUNICATIONS OF CENTRAL OHIO LLC; DUKENET COMMUNICATIONS HOLDINGS, LLC; DUKENET COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; ICI HOLDINGS, LLC; INSIGHT BLOCKER LLC; INSIGHT CAPITAL LLC; INSIGHT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY LLC; INSIGHT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY, L.P; INSIGHT COMMUNICATIONS MIDWEST, LLC; INSIGHT COMMUNICATIONS OF CENTRAL OHIO, LLC; INSIGHT COMMUNICATIONS OF KENTUCKY, L.P.; INSIGHT INTERACTIVE, LLC; INSIGHT KENTUCKY CAPITAL, LLC; INSIGHT KENTUCKY PARTNERS I, L.P.; INSIGHT KENTUCKY PARTNERS II, L.P.; INSIGHT MIDWEST HOLDINGS, LLC; INSIGHT MIDWEST, L.P.; INSIGHT PHONE OF INDIANA, LLC; INSIGHT PHONE OF KENTUCKY, LLC; INSIGHT PHONE OF OHIO, LLC; INTERACTIVE CABLE SERVICES, LLC; INTREPID ACQUISITION LLC; NAVISITE LLC; NEW WISCONSIN PROCUREMENT LLC; OCEANIC TIME WARNER CABLE LLC; PARITY ASSETS, LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE BUSINESS LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (ALABAMA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (ARIZONA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (CALIFORNIA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (COLORADO), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (HAWAII), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (IDAHO), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (ILLINOIS), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (INDIANA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (KANSAS), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (KENTUCKY), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (MAINE), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (MASSACHUSETTS), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (MICHIGAN), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (MISSOURI), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NEBRASKA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NEW HAMPSHIRE), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NEW JERSEY), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NEW MEXICO) LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NEW YORK), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (NORTH CAROLINA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (OHIO), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (PENNSYLVANIA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (SOUTH CAROLINA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (TENNESSEE), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (TEXAS), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (VIRGINIA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (WASHINGTON), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (WEST VIRGINIA), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INFORMATION SERVICES (WISCONSIN), LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INTERNATIONAL LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INTERNET HOLDINGS III LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INTERNET HOLDINGS LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE INTERNET LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE MEDIA LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE MIDWEST LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE NEW YORK CITY LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE NORTHEAST LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE PACIFIC WEST LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE SERVICES LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE SOUTHEAST LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE SPORTS LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE TEXAS LLC; TWC ADMINISTRATION LLC; TWC COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; TWC DIGITAL PHONE LLC; TWC MEDIA BLOCKER LLC; TWC NEWCO LLC; TWC NEWS AND LOCAL PROGRAMMING HOLDCO LLC; TWC NEWS AND LOCAL PROGRAMMING LLC; TWC REGIONAL SPORTS NETWORK I LLC; TWC SECURITY LLC; TWC SEE HOLDCO LLC; TWC WIRELESS LLC; TWC/CHARTER DALLAS CABLE ADVERTISING, LLC; TWCIS HOLDCO LLC; WISCONSIN PROCUREMENT HOLDCO LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS, LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS INFORMATION SERVICES (ALABAMA), LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS INFORMATION SERVICES (CALIFORNIA), LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS INFORMATION SERVICES (FLORIDA), LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS INFORMATION SERVICES (INDIANA), LLC; BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS INFORMATION SERVICES (MICHIGAN), LLC; BHN SPECTRUM INVESTMENTS, LLC; BHN HOME SECURITY SERVICES, LLC; AMERICAN CABLE ENTERTAINMENT COMPANY, LLC; ATHENS CABLEVISION, LLC; AUSABLE CABLE TV, LLC; BRESNAN BROADBAND HOLDINGS, LLC; BRESNAN BROADBAND OF COLORADO, LLC; BRESNAN BROADBAND OF MONTANA, LLC; BRESNAN BROADBAND OF UTAH, LLC; BRESNAN BROADBAND OF WYOMING, LLC; BRESNAN COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; BRESNAN DIGITAL SERVICES, LLC; BRESNAN MICROWAVE OF MONTANA, LLC; CABLE EQUITIES COLORADO, LLC; CABLE EQUITIES OF COLORADO MANAGEMENT LLC CC 10, LLC; CC FIBERLINK, LLC; CC MICHIGAN, LLC; CC SYSTEMS, LLC; CC V HOLDINGS, LLC; CC VI FIBERLINK, LLC; CC VI OPERATING COMPANY, LLC; CC VII FIBERLINK, LLC; CC VIII FIBERLINK, LLC; CC VIII HOLDINGS, LLC; CC VIII OPERATING, LLC; CC VIII, LLC; CCO FIBERLINK, LLC; CCO HOLDCO TRANSFERS VII, LLC; CCO LP, LLC; CCO NR HOLDINGS, LLC; CCO PURCHASING, LLC; CCO SOCAL I, LLC; CCO SOCAL II, LLC; CCO SOCAL VEHICLES, LLC; CCO TRANSFERS, LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (AL), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (CA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (CO), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (CT), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (GA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (IL), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (IN), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (KY), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (LA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MD), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MI), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MN), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MO), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MS), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (MT), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (NC), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (NE), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (NH), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (NV), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (NY), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (OH), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (OR), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (PA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (SC), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (TN), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (TX), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (UT), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (VA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (VT), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (WA), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (WI), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (WV), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES (WY), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES VIII (MI), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES VIII (MN), LLC; CHARTER ADVANCED SERVICES VIII (WI), LLC; CHARTER ADVERTISING OF SAINT LOUIS, LLC; CHARTER CABLE OPERATING COMPANY, LLC; CHARTER CABLE PARTNERS, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS ENTERTAINMENT I, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS ENTERTAINMENT II, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS ENTERTAINMENT, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS OF CALIFORNIA, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS OPERATING CAPITAL CORP.; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS OPERATING, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS PROPERTIES LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS V, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS VENTURES, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS VI, L.L.C.; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS VII, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; CHARTER DISTRIBUTION, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - ALABAMA, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - GEORGIA, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - ILLINOIS, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - MARYLAND II, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - MICHIGAN, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - MISSOURI, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - NEBRASKA, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - PENNSYLVANIA, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK - TENNESSEE, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK AR-CCVII, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK CA-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK CC VIII, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK CT-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK LA-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK MA-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK MS-CCVI, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK NC-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK NH-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK NV-CCVII, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK NY-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK OH-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK OR-CCVII, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK SC-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK TX-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK VA-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK VT-CCO, LLC; CHARTER FIBERLINK WA-CCVII, LLC; CHARTER HELICON, LLC; CHARTER HOME SECURITY, LLC; CHARTER LEASING HOLDING COMPANY, LLC; CHARTER LEASING OF WISCONSIN, LLC; CHARTER RMG, LLC; CHARTER STORES FCN, LLC; CHARTER VIDEO ELECTRONICS, LLC; FALCON CABLE COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; FALCON CABLE MEDIA, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; FALCON CABLE SYSTEMS COMPANY II, L.P.; FALCON CABLEVISION, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; FALCON COMMUNITY CABLE, L.P.; FALCON COMMUNITY VENTURES I LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; FALCON FIRST CABLE OF THE SOUTHEAST, LLC; FALCON FIRST, LLC; FALCON TELECABLE, A CALIFORNIA LIMITED PARTNERSHIP; FALCON VIDEO COMMUNICATIONS, L.P.; HELICON PARTNERS I, L.P.; HOMETOWN T.V., LLC; HPI ACQUISITION CO. LLC; INTERLINK COMMUNICATIONS PARTNERS, LLC; LONG BEACH, LLC; MARCUS CABLE ASSOCIATES, L.L.C.; MARCUS CABLE OF ALABAMA, L.L.C.; MARCUS CABLE, LLC; MIDWEST CABLE COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; PEACHTREE CABLE TV, L.P.; PEACHTREE CABLE TV, LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (AL), LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (CA), LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (GA), LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (NC), LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (TN), LLC; PHONE TRANSFERS (VA), LLC; PLATTSBURGH CABLEVISION, LLC; RENAISSANCE MEDIA LLC; RIFKIN ACQUISITION PARTNERS, LLC; ROBIN MEDIA GROUP, LLC; SCOTTSBORO TV CABLE, LLC TENNESSEE, LLC; THE HELICON GROUP, L.P.; VISTA BROADBAND COMMUNICATIONS, LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (AL), LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (CA) LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (GA), LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (NC), LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (TN), LLC; VOIP TRANSFERS (VA), LLC
To: THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST COMPANY, N.A.
Reel/Frame 046567/0090 →
CHANGE OF ADDRESS Recorded Nov 15, 2017
From: TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC
To: TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC
Reel/Frame 044456/0167 →
CORRECTIVE ASSIGNMENT TO CORRECT THE CONTRIBUTION AGREEMENT EXECUTED 12-31-2012 - AGREEMENT SHOULD NOT BE RECORDED AGAINST APPLICATION NUMBER 12131649. PREVIOUSLY RECORDED AT REEL: 030281 FRAME: 0473. ASSIGNOR(S) HEREBY CONFIRMS THE . Recorded Jul 11, 2016
From: TIME WARNER CABLE INC.
To: TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC
Reel/Frame 039903/0204 →
SECURITY INTEREST Recorded May 18, 2016
From: BRIGHT HOUSE NETWORKS, LLC; CHARTER COMMUNICATIONS OPERATING, LLC; TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC
To: BANK OF AMERICA, N.A., AS ADMINISTRATIVE AGENT
Reel/Frame 038747/0507 →
CONTRIBUTION AGREEMENT Recorded Apr 24, 2013
From: TIME WARNER CABLE INC.
To: TIME WARNER CABLE ENTERPRISES LLC
Reel/Frame 030281/0473 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Sep 28, 2011
From: RAMSDELL, SCOTT
To: TIME WARNER CABLE, INC.
Reel/Frame 026985/0149 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Sep 28, 2011
From: MAHONCHAK, CRAIG; SANTANGELO, BRYAN
To: TIME WARNER CABLE, INC.
Reel/Frame 026985/0188 →
Continuity (2)
Provisional Application 61493727 · Jun 6, 2011
Related Publication 20120308071A1 · Dec 6, 2012