Preventing tube failure in boilers
View Patent ↗The erosion-prone sections of the tubes in a circulating fluidized bed boiler are provided with a locally thickened sidewall without forming discontinuities on the outer surface of the tubes. This can be accomplished, for example, by replacing the erosion prone portion of the tube with a section having a smaller inside diameter, but the same outside diameter, or by replacing the erosion prone portion of the tube with a section having a thicker sidewall, but the same inside diameter, and smoothing over the outside discontinuity with an alloy coating. A useful alloy coating is also disclosed which can be used for this and other applications.
1. A method to reduce the wear of a refractory wall of a boiler, the refractory wall having a plurality of parallel tubes vertically disposed therein and interconnected by a webbing, each of the tubes extending upwardly from a refractory ledge of the refractory wall and defining a fire side in front of the webbing and a cold side behind the webbing, each tube having a cylindrical portion with a generally cylindrical outer shape; said method comprising:
thermal spraying a first coating onto a portion of the cylindrical portion of the plurality of tubes extending upward from the refractory ledge and the webbing therebetween at the fire side to thereby increase the thickness of the plurality of tubes and the webbing therebetween at the fire side, the first coating extending upwardly from the refractory ledge, wherein the first coating on the tubes has a thickness of at least 0.060 inches at a transition between the plurality of tubes and the refractory ledge, the thickness of a section of the first coating tapering upwardly to nil, wherein the first coating extents over a distance of at least 12 inches on the cylindrical portion of the plurality of tubes and webbing therebetween extending vertically upward from the refractory ledge; and
wherein a thickness of the first coating and a thickness of the fire side sidewall of the plurality of tubes, combined, defines a total material thickness at the fire side that is greater than a total material thickness of a cold side sidewall of the plurality of tubes at the cold side;
wherein the fire side sidewall of the plurality of tubes is opposite the cold side sidewall of the plurality of tubes; wherein
each of the plurality of tubes has a continuously uniform outside diameter extending from a point below the refractory ledge to an uppermost point at which the first coating is applied above the refractory ledge.
2. The method of claim 1 , wherein the section of the first coating tapered upwardly is tapered linearly.
3. The method of claim 1 , wherein the section of the first coating tapered upwardly is tapered from the refractory ledge.
4. The method of claim 2 , wherein the section of the first coating tapered upwardly is tapered linearly.
5. The method of claim 1 , wherein only one side of the plurality of tubes and webbing therebetween are coated.
6. The method of claim 5 , wherein a side of the plurality of tubes and webbing therebetween exposed to the heated portion of the boiler are coated.
7. The method of claim 1 , wherein the transition between the plurality of tubes and the refractory ledge is approximately 0-5 inches.
8. The method of claim 1 , further comprising:
thermal spraying a second coating onto the portion of the cylindrical portion of the plurality of tubes extending upward from the refractory ledge and the webbing therebetween and the first coating, the second coating extending upwardly from the refractory ledge, wherein the thickness of a section of the coating tapers upwardly to nil, and wherein the second coating extents over a distance of at least 12 inches on the cylindrical portion of the plurality of tubes and webbing therebetween extending vertically upward from the refractory ledge.
9. The method of claim 1 , wherein the thermal spray of the first coating includes:
providing a cored wire containing a chrome constituent and a boron constituent in the core of the wire, said wire further comprising a nickel or nickel alloy outer sheath,
melting the wire by an arc-based thermal spray technique to form a molten alloy coating composition, and
applying the molten alloy coating composition onto a substrate and permitting it to solidify to form an alloy coating deposit,
wherein the alloy coating deposit comprises at least 10 discrete discernible layers per 0:06 inch of coating of segregated incomplete alloy compositions,
wherein the alloy coating deposit comprises, in bulk on a weight basis, 39 to 66% nickel or nickel alloy, 29% to 51% Cr, and 2 to 8% B, the discrete layers having varying hardness and being in the range of from 30 RC to 72 RC, and
wherein the cored wire contains all the alloy constituents that comprise the final coating deposit.
10. The method of claim 1 , wherein the boiler is a fluidized bed.
11. The method of claim 1 , wherein the plurality of tubes are formed from steel and the first coating is applied by providing a wire having a metallic outer sheath and a powdered inner core, wherein the inner core comprises at least about 28% by weight of boron sourced from pure boron or a compound of boron and chrome sourced from pure chrome or a compound of chrome in an amount between about 67% and about 185% by weight of the amount of the boron; the thermal spraying of the first coating further includes:
melting the wire using an electric arc heat source to form a melt;
atomizing and spraying the melt onto the tubes by compressed gas;
wherein the composite wire is selected to form a coating on the substrate comprising the metal of the sheath, chrome, and boron, and
permitting the coating to solidify.