IP Library Granted Patent US 9,598,178
Granted Patent B2
US 9,598,178 · App. 14/478,076 · Granted Mar 21, 2017

Method for monitoring a degradation in an on-board device of an aircraft with automatic determination of a decision threshold

View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 9,598,178
App. No.
14/478,076
Granted
Mar 21, 2017
Kind
B2
Abstract

A method for monitoring a degradation in an on-board device of an aircraft, comprising a step of comparing an abnormality score obtained for a given flight of said aircraft with a decision threshold (S) and a step of transmitting an alert in the event of said decision threshold (S) being exceeded, said decision threshold (S) being automatically determined for a given probability of alert Pa, corresponding to the probability of an alert being transmitted during the monitoring method when said on-board device is healthy, by means of a plurality of steps, including a step of reading the antecedent of the continuous adjusted division function for the value 1−Peac, said antecedent corresponding to said decision threshold (S), with Peac being the elementary probability of exceeding the threshold for confirmation per k exceedances of threshold during n consecutive flights and being a function of the probability of alert Pa.

Claims (69)

1. A method for monitoring a degradation in an on-board device of an aircraft, implemented by a computer, the method comprising:

measuring physical parameters from a plurality of sensors on the on-board device of the aircraft;

transforming, using the computer, the measured physical parameters to obtain an abnormality score for a given flight of the aircraft;

comparing the abnormality score obtained for the given flight of the aircraft to a decision threshold; and

transmitting an alert when the decision threshold is exceeded,

wherein the decision threshold is automatically determined for a given probability of alert Pa, corresponding to a probability of an alert being transmitted during the monitoring method when the on-board device is undamaged, by:

computing a plurality of abnormality scores for a plurality of flights of the aircraft without degradation;

obtaining a distribution of a probability density of the plurality of abnormality scores, with the distribution being specific to a physical nature of the on-board device;

obtaining a continuous adjusted distribution function by adjusting the distribution using a non-parametric estimator of the probability density;

computing a continuous adjusted division function based on the continuous adjusted distribution function; and

determining the decision threshold by reading an antecedent of the continuous adjusted division function for a given value, the antecedent corresponding to the decision threshold,

wherein the given value is 1−Peac, where Peac is an elementary probability of exceeding the decision threshold for confirmation per k exceedances of the decision threshold during n consecutive flights and is obtained by the following formula:

Peac=B −1 (k, n−k+1) (Pa)

wherein B −1 (k, n−k+1) is an inverse Beta division function of parameters k and n−k+1 and Pa is the probability of alert.

2. The method for monitoring according to claim 1 , wherein the non-parametric estimator of the probability density is a Parzen window estimator.

3. The method for monitoring according to claim 2 , wherein the distribution is formed from a number N of abnormality scores for the plurality of flights of the aircraft without degradation, the distribution having an estimated standard deviation {circle around (σ)}, and a width h of the Parzen window is defined according to the following formula:

h

=

σ

^

(

4

3

*

N

)

1

/

5

4. The method for monitoring according to claim 1 , wherein the probability of alert Pa is obtained by the following formula:

Pa

=

Pe

(

1

-

Pe

)

·

(

1

-

β

)

a

priori

·

Pd

(

1

-

Pd

)

wherein:

Pe corresponds to the probability of the on-board device being undamaged when the alert is transmitted;

Pd corresponds to the probability of the degradation for the given flight; and

(1β) a priori corresponds to the probability of detecting an a priori degradation.

5. The method for monitoring according to claim 4 , further comprising:

deducing the probability of detecting the a posteriori degradation (1β) a posteriori by implementing the method for monitoring the degradation in the on-board device with the previously determined decision threshold for the plurality of abnormality scores formed for the plurality of flights of the aircraft with degradation (1β) a posteriori ;

determining a new probability of alert Pa as a function of the probability of detecting the a posteriori degradation (1β) a posteriori ;

determining the elementary probability of exceeding the threshold Peac based on the new probability of alert Pa; and

determining a new decision threshold that is refined based on the new elementary probability of exceeding the threshold Peac.

6. The method for monitoring according to claim 1 , further comprising:

predetermining values of k and n.

7. The method for monitoring according to claim 6 , wherein the value of n is selected before that of k and the value of k is selected as a function of that of n.

8. The method for monitoring according to claim 7 , wherein the value of n is selected in order to maximise the detection probability.

Assignments (3)
CORRECTIVE ASSIGNMENT TO CORRECT THE COVER SHEET TO REMOVE APPLICATION NOS. 10250419, 10786507, 10786409, 12416418, 12531115, 12996294, 12094637 12416422 PREVIOUSLY RECORDED ON REEL 046479 FRAME 0807. ASSIGNOR(S) HEREBY CONFIRMS THE CHANGE OF NAME. Recorded Aug 24, 2018
From: SNECMA
To: SAFRAN AIRCRAFT ENGINES
Reel/Frame 046939/0336 →
CHANGE OF NAME Recorded May 23, 2018
From: SNECMA
To: SAFRAN AIRCRAFT ENGINES
Reel/Frame 046479/0807 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Nov 12, 2014
From: MASSE, JEAN-REMI ANDRE; HMAD, OUADIE; GRALL-MAES, EDITH; BEAUSEROY, PIERRE JEAN EMILE
To: SNECMA; SAFRAN ENGINEERING SERVICES; UNIVERSITE DE TECHNOLOGIE DE TROYES
Reel/Frame 034158/0535 →