System to evaluate prosthetic sockets
Systems, methods, and software are provided for assessing manufacturing errors of a prosthetic socket to facilitate a clinical assessment of the socket. The embodiments disclosed herein may align and compare a manufactured socket shape to a desired socket shape to determine whether clinically significant errors are present in the manufactured socket. A mean radial error (MRE) may be calculated and compared to a set threshold. If the MRE falls below the threshold an interquartile range (IQR) may be calculated and compared to an IQR threshold. If the IQR falls below the IQR threshold, surface normal angle errors (SNAE) may be calculated and plotted to the surface model. If the SNAE plot does not include closed contour regions, the socket may proceed to patient fitting. If the MRE or IQR thresholds are exceeded, or if the SNAE plot indicates closed contour regions, the socket may be reshaped accordingly, prior to fitting.
1. A method of assessing a prosthetic socket shape for receiving a residual limb of a patient, the method comprising:
calculating surface normal angle errors between points on a first digital model and corresponding points on a second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
plotting the calculated surface normal angle errors to a surface model; and
displaying the plotted surface normal angle errors to an operator;
accepting or rejecting the prosthetic socket shape in response to the plotted surface normal angle errors;
calculating an average radial difference between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and determining whether the mean radial error is above or below a set threshold;
wherein the set threshold has a value between 0.24 mm and 0.29 mm.
2. A method of assessing a prosthetic socket shape for receiving a residual limb of a patient, the method comprising:
calculating surface normal angle errors between points on a first digital model and corresponding points on a second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
plotting the calculated surface normal angle errors to a surface model; and
displaying the plotted surface normal angle errors to an operator;
accepting or rejecting the prosthetic socket shape in response to the plotted surface normal angle errors;
determining whether an interquartile range of radial error is above or below a second threshold.
3. The method of claim 2 , wherein the second threshold value has a value between 0.34 mm and 0.42 mm.
4. The method of claim 2 , further comprising the step of regionally reshaping or resizing the prosthetic socket shape when the interquartile range of radial error is above the second threshold value.
5. A method of objectively assessing a prosthetic socket shape, the method comprising:
aligning a first digital model with a second digital model using an alignment function, the alignment function at least depending on a volume difference between the first digital model and the second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
calculating an average radial difference between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model; and
determining whether the mean radial error is either above or below a first threshold, the first threshold having a value between 0.24 mm and 0.29 mm; and
resizing or reshaping the prosthetic socket shape when the mean radial error is above the first threshold.
6. The method of claim 5 , further comprising the step of scanning an interior surface of the prosthetic socket shape to create the digital model of the interior surface.
7. The method of claim 5 , further comprising determining whether an inner quartile range of radial error is above a second threshold value when the mean radial error is below the first threshold value.
8. The method of claim 7 , further comprising the steps of:
resizing or reshaping the prosthetic socket shape when the interquartile range of radial error is above the second threshold;
calculating surface normal angle errors between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model; and
plotting the calculated surface normal angle error to a surface model when the interquartile range of radial error is below the second threshold.
9. A method of objectively assessing a prosthetic socket shape, the method comprising:
calculating radial differences between points on a first digital model and corresponding points on a second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape; and
determining whether an interquartile range of radial error is above a threshold value, the threshold value having a value greater than 0.3 mm; and
regionally reshaping or resizing the prosthetic socket shape when the interquartile range of radial error is above the second threshold value.
10. A method of objectively assessing a prosthetic socket shape, the method comprising:
scanning an interior surface of a prosthetic socket shape to create a first digital model;
calculating radial differences between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape; and
determining whether an interquartile range of radial error is above a threshold value, the threshold value having a value greater than 0.3 mm.
11. The method of claim 9 , wherein the threshold has a value between 0.34 mm and 0.42 mm; and
wherein the method further comprises the step of:
plotting surface normal angle errors between the first digital model and the second digital model to a surface model when the interquartile range is below the threshold.
12. A non-transitory computer readable media, comprising:
an alignment module for aligning a first digital model with a second digital model based at least on a volume difference between the first digital model and the second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
an analysis module configured to calculate surface normal angle errors between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and configured to plot the surface normal angle errors to a surface model;
wherein the analysis module is further configured to calculate radial errors between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and to determine whether an interquartile range of radial error exceeds an interquartile range threshold.
13. A non-transitory computer readable media for assessing a prosthetic socket shape, the system comprising:
an alignment module for aligning a first digital model with a second digital model based at least on the a volume difference between the first digital model and the second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
an analysis module configured to calculate an average radial difference between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and configured to determine whether the mean radial error is either above or below a set threshold, the threshold having a value between 0.24 mm and 0.29 mm.
14. A non-transitory computer readable media for assessing a prosthetic socket shape, the system comprising:
an alignment module for aligning a first digital model with a second digital model based at least on a volume difference between the digital model and the desired shape, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape;
an analysis module configured to calculate radial differences between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and configured to determine whether an interquartile range of radial error is either above or below a set threshold, the threshold having a value greater than 0.3 mm.
15. The non-transitory computer readable media of claim 14 , wherein the threshold has a value between 0.34 mm and 0.42 mm.
16. A non-transitory computer-readable storage medium comprising a set of computer executable instructions for facilitating clinical assessment of a prosthetic socket shape, wherein the execution of the instructions by a computer processor causes the processor to carry out the steps of:
aligning a first digital model with a second digital model using an alignment function, the alignment function at least depending on a volume difference between the first digital model and the second digital model, the first digital model corresponding to the prosthetic socket shape and the second digital model corresponding to a desired shape; and
analyzing the socket shape by performing at least one of the following:
calculating an average radial difference between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and providing a first signal when the mean radial error exceeds a first threshold, the first threshold having a value greater than 0.18 mm;
calculating radial differences between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and providing a second signal when an interquartile range of radial error is above a second threshold, the second threshold having a value greater than 0.3 mm; and
calculating surface normal angle errors between points on the first digital model and corresponding points on the second digital model and plotting the calculated surface normal angle errors to a surface model;
outputting at least one of the first signal, the second signal, and the surface model to an operator.
17. The non-transitory computer-readable storage medium of claim 16 , wherein the steps further comprise receiving the first digital model from a scanning system.
18. The non-transitory computer-readable storage medium of claim 16 , wherein the first threshold value is between 0.24 mm and 0.29 mm.
19. The non-transitory computer-readable storage medium of claim 18 , wherein the second threshold value is between 0.34 mm and 0.42 mm.