IP Library Granted Patent US 12,557,740
Granted Patent B2
US 12,557,740 · App. 15/676,899 · Granted Feb 24, 2026

Greenhouse and forced greenhouse climate control system and method

Inventors: Casey Houweling (Delta, CA); Geurt Reinders (Almelo, NL)
A01G9/246A01G9/14A01G9/24Y02A40/25
View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 12,557,740
App. No.
15/676,899
Granted
Feb 24, 2026
Kind
B2
Abstract

A greenhouse is disclosed that generally comprises an enclosed growing section with an enclosed end gable adjacent to the growing section. The end gable is arranged to flow air into the growing section. Air distribution tubes are included within the growing section with the tubes arranged to provide for substantially uniform air flow into the growing section. The air tubes can also be arranged to compensate for heat differential between the air in the tubes and in the growing section.

Claims (34)

1 . A greenhouse, comprising:

a growing section; and

an air or gas distribution system within said growing section,

said distribution system comprising one or more conduits for distributing air or gas within said greenhouse with the one or more conduits carrying air or gas having different pressures along the length of the one or more conduits, the one or more conduits being arranged to provide substantially equal air distribution of air or gas throughout the growing section,

each of said conduits comprising a conduit pair comprising an inner conduit within and surrounded by a respective outer conduit;

with a main air flow entering said growing section from said distribution system by passing said main air flow into said conduits,

said inner conduit comprising inner conduit holes to allow said main air flow within said conduits to pass from within said inner conduit, and said outer conduit comprising outer conduit holes each of which are fully offset from all each of said inner conduit holes in its respective conduit pair, said outer conduit holes configured to allow air passing from said inner conduit to pass into said growing section, the pattern of the outer conduit holes changing along the length of the outer conduit so that different amounts of air are allowed to pass out of said outer conduit at different locations along said outer conduit to compensate for pressure variations;

one or more compartments are formed between each of said inner conduits and its respective outer conduit, wherein said main air flow from said inner conduit passes though the inner conduit holes into the one or more compartments;

wherein said inner and outer conduit holes are configured to compensate for substantially all of a turbulence or a directional flow of said main air flow within said conduits by dissipating much of the turbulence or directional flow of the main air flow in said one or more compartments before exiting through the outer conduit holes, to provide substantially equal distribution of air or gas throughout said growing section.

2 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein said conduits are arranged to compensate for the temperature differential between said main air flow and said growing section.

3 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein the amount of air exiting said conduits varies along the length of said conduits to compensate for turbulence or pressure differences within said conduits.

4 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein the distance between said inner and outer conduit holes along said conduits is varied to compensate for turbulence or pressure differences within said conduits.

5 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein the size of said holes is varied along said conduits to compensate for turbulence or pressure differences within said conduits.

6 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , comprising a plurality of said compartments in each conduit pair.

7 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , comprising a plurality of compartments in each conduit pair to reduce directional forces on air exiting said conduits.

8 . The greenhouse of claim 7 , wherein said compartments are arranged to compensate for the temperature differential between said main air flow and said growing section.

9 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein each of said inner conduits is coaxial with its respective outer conduit.

10 . The greenhouse of claim 1 , wherein each of said inner conduits and each of said outer conduits has a substantially constant diameter.

11 . The greenhouse of claim 4 , wherein the distance between said inner conduit holes and the distance between said outer conduit holes increases as distance from an inlet of said inner and outer conduits increases.

12 . A greenhouse air distribution system, comprising:

a plurality of inner conduits and outer conduits forming air distribution conduits to distribute air within a greenhouse, wherein each of said air distribution conduits comprises one of said inner conduits within and surrounded by a respective one of said outer conduits, with two or more compartments formed between said inner and outer conduits; and

a system for providing a main air flow to the interior of said inner conduits, the air pressure within each of said inner conduits varying along its length, said inner conduits comprising inner conduit holes to allow air to pass from within said inner conduits, and said outer conduits comprising outer conduit holes, wherein said outer conduit holes allow for air passing from said inner conduits to pass into said greenhouse and wherein the pattern of the outer tube holes varying along the length of the outer conduit so that different amounts of air are allowed to pass out of the outer conduit at different locations along the outer tube to compensate for pressure variations along the length of said outer conduit, wherein each of said inner conduit holes is offset from all outer conduit holes in each of said air distribution conduits, wherein said inner and outer conduit holes are configured to compensate for a directional flow of said main air flow by dissipating substantially all of a directional nature of the main air flow in said one or more compartments before exiting through the outer tube holes to allow said air distribution conduits to provide for a substantially uniform air distribution along their lengths.

13 . The system of claim 12 , wherein said conduits have interior compartments.

14 . The system of claim 12 , wherein the pattern or size of said inner or outer conduit holes vary to compensate for pressure variations.

15 . The system of claim 12 , wherein said conduits are arranged to compensate for a temperature differential between said main air flow and said greenhouse.

16 . The system of claim 12 , comprising a plurality of compartments between said inner and outer conduits.

17 . The system of claim 12 , wherein each of said inner conduits is coaxial with its respective outer conduit.

18 . A greenhouse, comprising:

a growing section;

a climate control system comprising a substantially enclosed end portion adjacent to and outside said growing section, said end portion comprising one or more vents and one or more mechanisms selectively moveable to cooperate with said one or more vents to control air flow through said one or more vents; and

an air or gas distribution system within said growing section, said distribution system comprising one or more air distribution conduits for distributing air or gas within said greenhouse;

wherein said air distribution conduits run along the floor of growing section and each air distribution conduit comprises an inner conduit within and coaxial with a respective outer conduit, and one or more compartments between each of said inner conduits and its respective outer conduit;

said air distribution conduits carrying air or gas having different pressures along their length, with a main air flow entering said growing section from said distribution system passing into said air distribution conduits, said inner conduit of each of said air distribution conduits comprising inner conduit holes to allow said main air flow within said conduits to pass from within said inner conduit, and said outer conduit of each of said air distribution conduits comprising outer conduit holes that allow air passing from its said inner conduit to pass into said growing section, wherein each of said inner conduit holes is fully offset from each of said outer conduit holes, and wherein said inner conduit holes or outer conduit holes has a varying pattern;

wherein said inner and outer conduit holes in each of said air distribution conduits and said one or more compartments are configured to compensate for a directional flow of said main air flow within said conduits flow by dissipating substantially all of the directional a directional nature a turbulence of the main air flow before exiting through the outer tube holes to provide substantially equal distribution of air or gas throughout said growing section.

Assignments (3)
CORRECTIVE ASSIGNMENT TO CORRECT THE COVERSHEET PREVIOUSLY RECORDED AT REEL: 060424 FRAME: 0709. ASSIGNOR(S) HEREBY CONFIRMS THE ASSIGNMENT. Recorded Apr 24, 2023
From: GLASS INVESTMENTS PROJECTS, INC.
To: HOUWELING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTIES, INC.
Reel/Frame 063440/0293 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Jul 1, 2022
From: GLASS INVESTMENTS PROJECTS, INC.
To: HOUWELING INTELLECTUAL PROPERTIES, INC. C/O FERGUSON CASE ORR PATERSON LLP
Reel/Frame 060424/0799 →
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Feb 1, 2019
From: HOUWELING NURSERIES OXNARD, INC.
To: GLASS INVESTMENTS PROJECTS, INC.
Reel/Frame 048217/0960 →
Continuity (4)
Continuation 12636549 · Dec 11, 2009
Continuation In Part 11824159 · Jun 28, 2007
Provisional Application 60817755 · Jun 29, 2006
Related Publication 20170339848A1 · Nov 30, 2017
References Cited (347)
US 815093A · Keeney · 1906 [cited by applicant]
US 1506904A · Harrison · 1924 [cited by applicant]
US 1817384A · Lewis · 1931 [cited by examiner]
US 2193911A · Wright · 1940 [cited by applicant]
US 3124903A · Truhan · 1964 [cited by examiner]
US 3274730A · Bose · 1966 [cited by applicant]
US 3289567A · Renner · 1966 [cited by applicant]
US 3348922A · Bose · 1967 [cited by applicant]
US 3404618A · Jacobs · 1968 [cited by applicant]
US 3520244A · Gaines, Jr. · 1970 [cited by examiner]
US 3747501A · Honda · 1973 [cited by applicant]
US 3807088A · Jones · 1974 [cited by applicant]
US 3824909A · Horneff · 1974 [cited by examiner]
US 3949522A · Kehl · 1976 [cited by examiner]
US 4047328A · Kehl · 1977 [cited by applicant]
US 4163342A · Fogg · 1979 [cited by applicant]
US 4170930A · Lind · 1979 [cited by applicant]
US 4196544A · Davis · 1980 [cited by examiner]
US 4290242A · Gregory, Jr. · 1981 [cited by examiner]
US 4292762A · Fogg · 1981 [cited by examiner]
US 4557732A · Hahnke · 1985 [cited by applicant]
US 4567732A · Landstrom · 1986 [cited by applicant]
US 4567939A · Dumbeck · 1986 [cited by applicant]
US 4586342A · Morishita · 1986 [cited by applicant]
US 4707995A · Assaf · 1987 [cited by applicant]
US 4718130A · Steinback · 1988 [cited by applicant]
US 4739627A · Baumann · 1988 [cited by applicant]
US 4916642A · Kaiser · 1990 [cited by applicant]
US 5001659A · Watabe · 1991 [cited by applicant]
US 5001859A · Sprung · 1991 [cited by applicant]
US 5101593A · Bhatt · 1992 [cited by applicant]
US 5212903A · Talbott · 1993 [cited by applicant]
US 5224542A · Hemsath · 1993 [cited by applicant]
US 5299383A · Takakura · 1994 [cited by applicant]
US 5315834A · Garunts · 1994 [cited by applicant]
US 5392611A · Assaf · 1995 [cited by applicant]
US 5493808A · Munday · 1996 [cited by applicant]
US 5553417A · Chambers · 1996 [cited by applicant]
US 5713154A · Goldstein · 1998 [cited by applicant]
US 5813168A · Clendening · 1998 [cited by applicant]
US 6006471A · Sun · 1999 [cited by applicant]
US 6578319B1 · Cole · 2003 [cited by applicant]
US 6705043B1 · Opdam · 2004 [cited by applicant]
US 6978573B2 · Van Der Heijden · 2005 [cited by applicant]
US 7228657B2 · Brault · 2007 [cited by applicant]
US 8707617B2 · Houweling · 2014 [cited by applicant]
US 9730397B2 · Houweling · 2017 [cited by examiner]
US 11412668B2 · Houweling · 2022 [cited by applicant]
US 20040194371A1 · Kinnis · 2004 [cited by applicant]
US 20050005510A1 · Brault · 2005 [cited by applicant]
US 20060021375A1 · Wetzel · 2006 [cited by applicant]
US 20080000151A1 · Houweling · 2008 [cited by applicant]
US 20100126062A1 · Houweling · 2010 [cited by applicant]
CA 2592674 · 2007 [cited by applicant]
CA 2592674A1 · 2007 [cited by applicant]
DE 3331284 · 1985 [cited by applicant]
DE 3331284A1 · 1985 [cited by applicant]
EP 0517432A1 · 1992 [cited by applicant]
EP 0856709 · 1998 [cited by applicant]
EP 1199922B1 · 2002 [cited by applicant]
EP 1464218A1 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
EP 1464219 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
EP 1464219A1 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
EP 1598314A1 · 2005 [cited by applicant]
FR 2713317 · 1995 [cited by applicant]
GB 693142 · 1953 [cited by applicant]
GB 1242500 · 1971 [cited by applicant]
GB 1242500A · 1971 [cited by applicant]
GB 2135442 · 1984 [cited by applicant]
GB 2135442A · 1984 [cited by applicant]
JP 2008304111A · 2008 [cited by applicant]
NL 6913348A · 1971 [cited by applicant]
NL 8200360 · 1983 [cited by applicant]
NL 8200360A · 1983 [cited by applicant]
NL 9001674 · 1992 [cited by applicant]
NL 9001674A · 1992 [cited by applicant]
NL 9001874A · 1992 [cited by applicant]
NL 200012 · 2002 [cited by applicant]
NL 1021856 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
NL 1021856C2 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
NL 1023053 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
NL 1023053C2 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
NL 2000152 · 2008 [cited by applicant]
NL 2000152C2 · 2008 [cited by applicant]
NL 1032779C2 · 2008 [cited by applicant]
NL 1037250 · 2011 [cited by applicant]
NL 1038219 · 2011 [cited by applicant]
WO 8000486A1 · 1980 [cited by applicant]
WO WO1980000486A1 · 1980 [cited by applicant]
WO 8606928 · 1986 [cited by applicant]
WO 8606928A1 · 1986 [cited by applicant]
WO 0076296 · 2000 [cited by applicant]
WO 0076296A1 · 2000 [cited by applicant]
WO 03012344 · 2003 [cited by applicant]
WO 2004032606A1 · 2004 [cited by applicant]
WO 2008002686A2 · 2008 [cited by applicant]
WO 2011028100 · 2011 [cited by applicant]
WO 2012078927 · 2012 [cited by applicant]
WO 2017210220A1 · 2017 [cited by applicant]
Intention to grant from corresponding European Patent Appl. No. 10 720 683.1-1655, dated Nov. 22, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Second Office Action from Israeli Patent Appl. No. 227472, dated Oct. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
International Preliminary Report on Patentability from Appl. No. PCT/US2007/017083, dated Jan. 6, 2009. [cited by applicant]
Examination Report from European Patent Appl. No. 10 720 683.1-1655, dated Feb. 2, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Full Patent Examination Report No. Tre: AU 2010328690, dated Nov. 19, 2013,. [cited by applicant]
Letter from AA Thomton to EPO re: Response to EPO Summons to Oral Proceedings, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Sep. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Letter from AA Thornton to EPO re: Opposition against EP2031957, dated Jul. 28, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Communication from EPO sending Minutes, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Feb. 13, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Mr. William Hunter in the matter of Patent Appl. No. 2010328690. [cited by applicant]
Statutory Declaration in the matter of Aus. Patent Appl. No. 2010328690. [cited by applicant]
Examination Report from Canadian Patent Appl. No. 2,777,694, dated Feb. 13, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Jelle Schconderbeek and attachment. [cited by applicant]
W.J. Roberts, “Environmental Control of Greenhouses”, Center for controlled Environment Agriculture, Cook College, Rutgers University, 19 pages. [cited by applicant]
“Semi-gesloten kas bokst op tegen woestijnklimaat” by Jelle Schoondereek. [cited by applicant]
“EuroFresh Tinkers With Greenhouse Design”, by J. Benton Jones, Jr., www.growingedge.com. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action from corresponding Mexican Patent Appl. No. MX/a/2012/005610, dated Aug. 11, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Wayback Machine 2014 Calendar on http://www.borneroup.nl/welcome/innovations; Date Downloaded Feb. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1010 of the Complaint for Damages and Injunctive Relief for: Patent Infringement 35 U.S.C. § 271 for Case 2:16-cv-04291; Filed Jun. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1002 Reisinger Figures; Dated Dec. 13, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Office Action from U.S. Appl. No. 12/636,549. dated Apr. 19, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Brief Description of Second Office Action from Israell Patent Appl. No. 227472, dated Oct. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Onderglas, Klimmat/Verwarming. No. 12, Dec. 2006. Jaargang 3 Gesolten of semi-qesolten. [cited by applicant]
International Search Report From PCT/US2007/017083. Dated: Jan. 15, 2008. [cited by applicant]
Office Action dated Dec. 8, 2020 for U.S. Appl. No. 14/174,043 (pp. 1-17). [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2023 of Environmentally friendly greenhouses in Camarillo impresses experts on http://archive.vcstar.com/business/environmentally-friendly-grecnhouscs-in-camanilo-impresses-cxports-ep-3718882… [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Letter from Opponent of 01.07.2020 to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Lettre from Opponent of 12.4.18 to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Copy of Intermediate Communication to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Opposition to European Patent No. EP2521436. Mar. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Office Action dated Jun. 9, 2021 for U.S. Appl. No. 14/174,043 (pp. 1-6). [cited by applicant]
Office Action dated Jul. 7, 2021 for U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 (pp. 1-15). [cited by applicant]
Translation of Mexican Office Action for App. No. MX/a/2018/001526, dated Oct. 14, 2021, 2 pages. [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Letter from Opponent of Jan. 7, 2020 to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Lettre from Opponent of Dec. 4, 2018 to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Brief Communication Intermediate Communication to European Patent No. 2521436. [cited by applicant]
Letter to the EPO Boards of Appeal in the Opposition against European Patent No. EP2521436. Submitted Nov. 2, 2020. 10 pages. [cited by applicant]
Office Action (Non-Final Rejection) dated Nov. 23, 2021 for U.S. Appl. No. 14/174,043 (pp. 1-6). [cited by applicant]
Office Action (Final Rejection) dated Feb. 16, 2022 for U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 (pp. 1-16). [cited by applicant]
Office Action (Notice of Allowance and Fees Due (PTOL-85) dated Apr. 13, 2022 for U.S. Appl. No. 14/174,043 (pp. 1-8) . [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2023 of Environmentally friendly greenhouses in Camarillo impresses experts on http://archive.vcstar.com/business/environmentally-friendly-grecnhouscs-in-camanllo-impresses-cxpcrts-ep-3718882… [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2022 of Innovation on http://www.houwelings.com/files-2/innovation.php; Downloaded Apr. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2021 of the Response to Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Jun. 21, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2020 of the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Mar. 15, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Amy Candeloro for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Oct. 2, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 2035 of Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary, Eleventh Edition for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Final Written Decision for Case IPR 2014-00309; Dated Mar. 23, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 2033 for Case IPR 2017-00476, “The Snack: Dave's Specialty Produce”; dated Sep. 2017. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 2032 for Case IPR 2017-00476, “The Packer: U.S. Grants patent for Ultra-Clima greenhouse system”; dated Feb. 26, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 2031 for Case IPR 2017-00476, “Ventura County Star: Greenhouse design and patent bring fewer pests and more revenue to Houweling's Tomatoes”; Dated Apr. 19, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2019 of the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Nov. 12, 2010. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2018 of the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Mar. 25, 2010. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2017 of the Notice of Allowance for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Jan. 30, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2016 of the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Sep. 25, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2015 of the Response to the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Aug. 30, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2014 of the Office Action tor U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Jul. 30, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-004/6 Exhibit 2013 of “Air Movement”, Chapter 6, by Robert J. Downs and Donald T. Krizek. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2012; NJAES Research Greenhouse on Rutgers New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station https://niaes.rutgers.edu/research-areenhouse/; Downloaded on April. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2011; Cornell University Agricultural Experiment Station Science for Life Greenhouses & Growth Chambers. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2010; Cornell University Greenhouses and Growth Chambers on https://cuaes.cals.cornell.edu/greenhouses; Downloaded on Apr. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2009 ; Duke Trinity College of Arts & Sciences, Biology, Phytotron overview on https://bioloav.duke.edu/facilities/phYtotron; Downloaded on Apr. 11, 2107. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2008; NC State University Phytotron on https://phvtotron.ncsu.edu/; Downloaded Apr. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 37 C.F.R. § 42.108 for Case IPR 2016-01309; Dated Dec. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Decision Denying Institution of Inter Partes Review 37 C.F.R. § 42,108 for Case IPR 2016-00014; Dated Mar. 23, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2003 of the Oxford American Dictionary and Thesaurus with Language Guide edition 2003. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Alexander Turkewitsch in Support of Patent Owner's Preliminary Response to Petition for Inter Partes Review for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Apr. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 1032; Bom Group; Third Party Observations in Opposition against European Patent EP2031957; Aug. 28, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Second Office Action for Israeli Application No. 227472; Dated Oct. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
First Examination Report from Corresponding New Zealand Application No. 611982; Dated Nov. 26, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Examiner Report on Canadian Application No. 2,620,897; Dated Jan. 16, 2015. [cited by applicant]
First Exam Report for New Zealand Application No. 705354; Dated Mar. 5, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Direction to Request Examination from Australian Application No. 2011338274; Dated Apr. 14, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Patent Examination Report for Australian Application No. 2011338274; Dated Sep. 22, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Final Written Decision tor Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jun. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Videotaped Deposition of Alexander Turkewitsch for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Dec. 13, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Second Declaration of Merle H. Jensen, PH.D. for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jan. 5, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Martin Van Zeijl for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 1, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1028 of Pictures for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1027 Drawing from Turkewitsch Deposition for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1025 Picture for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1024 Figure for Case IPR2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1023 Doorsnede Sunergiekas Figures P.L.J. Bom Groep for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1022 Figure for Case IPR 2017-00476. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1018 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Greenhouses Advanced technology for Protected Horticulture, by Joe J. Hanan; Dated Jan. 14, 1998. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1017 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Ecosystems of the World “20” Greenhouse Ecosystems, Copy 1; 1999. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1016 of the Response to the Office Action for U.S. Appl. No. 11/824,159; Dated Nov. 12, 2010. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1015 of the Appeal Decision of European Patent No. 2031957; Dated Jun. 27, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1014 of the Decision Revoking the European Patent for European Patent No. 2031957; Dated Feb. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1012 of the Proceedings for European Application No. 07810937.8; Dated Feb. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Exhibit 1011 of the Merriam Webster's Collegiate Dictionary, Tenth Edition; Dated 1997. [cited by applicant]
Benton Jones Jr., J. “EuroFresh Tinkers Wth Greenhouse Design”, www.growingedge.com. May 26, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Jelle Schoonderbeek and attachment. Nov. 25, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Observations by a third party from European Patent Application No. 10720683.1-1655/2521436. dated Feb. 6, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Official Action from corresponding European Appl. No. 201291033, dated Aug. 19, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Opposition from Australian Patent Appl. No. 2010328690, dated Aug. 15, 2014. [cited by applicant]
International Preliminary Report on Patentability for International Application No. PCT/US2007/017083. dated Jan. 6, 2009. 7 pages. [cited by applicant]
Examination Report from European Patent Appl. No. 10 720 683.1-1655, dated Feb. 12, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Brief Description of third Office Action from Israeli Patent Appl. No. 227472, dated May 3, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Allowance from Canadian Patent Office, Appl. No. 2,777,694, dated Aug. 4, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Office Action from Eurasian Patent Appl. No. 201291033, dated Aug. 1, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Document submitted in opposition proceeding, AU 2010328690, dated Nov. 8, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Opponent's Supplementary Outline in Response, AU 2010328690, dated Dec. 7, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Amendment Amending a Specification re: AU 2010328690, Oct. 22, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Patent Oppositions Letter re: AU 2010328690, dated Dec. 15, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Full Patent Examination Report No. 1 re: AU 2010328690, dated Nov. 19, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Mr. William Hunter re: AU 2010328690, dated May 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Ms. Bianca Capra re: AU 2010328690, dated Feb. 12, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Statutory Declaration of Mr. Hubertus Wilhelmus Albertus Dries re: AU 2010328690, dated Jul. 27, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Statutory Declaration of Dr. Emilie Sauret re: AU 2010328690, dated Jul. 27, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Houweling Decision re: Upholding Patent, AU 2010328690, dated Feb. 12, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Houweling Outline of Submissions re: AU 2010328690, dated Nov. 16, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Article “Evaporative Cooling for Greenhouses”, Paassen, et al. Diest voor Landbouwkundig Onderzoek: Instituut voor Merchanisatie Arbied en Gebouwen (IMAG-DLO), Wageningen. Technische Universiteit Delft (TUD Koudetechnie… [cited by applicant]
Communication from EPO re: Third Party Observations, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Feb. 10, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Letter from Opponent/Cramwinckel Consultancy/J.M. van der Hoeven to EPO re: Opposition Division, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Oct. 16, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Submission in Opposition Proceedings from EPO listing documents, Application No. 07810937.8, Sep. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Letter from AA Thornton to EPO re: Response to EPO Summons to Oral Proceedings, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Sep. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Letter from AA Thornton to EPO re: Opposition against EP2031957, dated Jul. 28, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Letter from EPO to Nicholas South at A.A. Thornton re: Submission in opposition proceedings with document listed. Dated Jul. 28, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Communication from EPO to A.A, Thornton re: Oral Proceedings, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Oct. 16, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Communication from EPO sending Minutes, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Feb. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Acknowledgment of Receipt EPO filing receipt re: Application No. 07810937.8, dated Jul. 28, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Communication from EPO to A.A. Thornton re: Observations by Third Party, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Sep. 7, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Acknowledgment of Receipt re: Opponent Submissions, Application No. EP07810937.8, dated Sep. 30, 2015. [cited by applicant]
EPO communication re: Revocation of EP patent, Appeal & Grounds of Appeal, dated Feb. 15, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Summons to Attend Oral Proceedings, Application No. 07810937.8, dated Jul. 17, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Official Action from Eurasian Patent Appl. No. 201291033, dated Oct. 27, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Allowance from corresponding Mexican Patent Appl. No. MX/a/2012/005610, dated Dec. 26, 2014. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action for Mexican Application No. MX/a/2012/005610; Dated Aug. 11, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Acceptance/First Examination Report from corresponding New Zealand Patent Appl. No. 599383, dated Aug. 16, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Intention to Grant for European Application No. 10 720683.1-1655; Dated Nov. 22, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Certificate of grant from corresponding Australian Patent No. 2010328690, dated Jul. 14, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Prosecution History of European Patent Application No. 07810937.8. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action from Israeli Patent Appl. No. 227472, dated Feb. 17, 2015. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action from Israeli Patent Appl. No. 220017, dated Oct. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Office Action from corresponding Eurasian Patent Appl. No. 201291033/31, dated Mar. 28, 2016. [cited by applicant]
“Evaluation of an Experimental Greenhouse Film with Improved Energy Performance” by Simpkins, et al. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action from corresponding Israel Patent Application No. 193844. dated Aug. 16. 2011. [cited by applicant]
Further Office Action from Israel Patent Appl. No. 193844 dated Jul. 10, 2012. [cited by applicant]
Office Action for counterpart Canadian Patent Application No. 2,592,674 dated Sep. 29, 2011. [cited by applicant]
International Search Report for International Application No. PCT/US2007/017083. dated Jan. 15, 2008. 3 pages. [cited by applicant]
P.L.J. Bom Groep, Press information distributed at the Horti Fair Nov. 2, 2005. 5 pages. [cited by applicant]
Gabot.de webpage retrieved Dec. 10, 2005. [cited by applicant]
EnerDes “Invention of the Semi-Closed Greenhouse” retrieved Oct. 25, 2016 from http://enerdes.com/invention-semi-closed-greenhouse/. [cited by applicant]
International Preliminary Report on Patentability for International Application No. PCT/US2010/001374. dated Jul. 29, 2013. 4 pages. [cited by applicant]
Netherlands Patent Application No. 1037250 filed Sep. 3, 2009 on behalf of Priva B.V. [cited by applicant]
Record of Oral Hearing for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 13, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Strike Exhibits 2040-2043 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 23, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Motion to Strike Exhibits 2040-2043 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 16, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Supplemental Mandatory Notices for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 7, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence tor Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Mar. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Reply to Petitioner's Opposition to Motion to Exclude Evidence for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Opposition to Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 20, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Order Trial Hearing Under 37 C.F.R. 42.70 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 10, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Request for Oral Argument for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Motion to Exclude Evidence for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Request for Oral Argument for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Order Denying Authorization for Motion to Strike and Request for Sur-Reply 37 C.F.R. 42.5 and 42.20 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jan. 31, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Filing of Jan. 23, 2018 Teleconference Transcript for Case IPR 2017-0076. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.64 (b)(1); Dated Jan. 16, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Reply to Patent Owner's Response; Dated Jan. 8, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Notice of Deposition of Alexander Turkewitsch for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Nov. 27, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Objections to Patent Owner's Evidence for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Oct. 10, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Opposition to Institution of Inter Partes Review for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Oct. 2, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Deposition of Merle H. Jensen, PH.D. for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Aug. 23, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Joint Stipulation of Extension of Time For Due Dates 1 and 2 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Aug. 23, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Objections to Petitioner's Evidence Under 37 C.F.R. § 42.64(b)(1) for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jun. 30, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Scheduling Order and General instructions 37 C.F.R. § 42.5 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jun. 16, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Decision Granting Institution of Inter Partes Review 37 C.F.R. § 42.108 for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jun. 16, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Supplemental Mandatory Notices for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated May 26, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Preliminary Response to Petition for Inter Partes Review for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Apr. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Supplemental Mandatory Notices for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Apr. 4, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Power of Attorney for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 27, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Patent Owner's Supplemental Mandatory Notices for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 27, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Notice of Filing Date Accorded to Petition and Time for Filing Patent Owner Preliminary Response for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jan. 11, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Houweling Nurseries Oxnard, Inc.'s Mandatory Notices Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 42.8(a)(2) for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Jan. 5, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Petitioner's Power of Attorney in an Inter Partes Review for U.S. Pat. No. 8,707,617; Dated Apr. 29, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Petition for Inter Partes Review for U.S. Pat. No. 8,707,617; Dated Dec. 14, 2016. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Amy Candeloro for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Feb. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Opponents Observations in preparation to the Oral Proceedings for Application No. EP07810937.8; Dated Sep. 25, 2015. [cited by applicant]
Timeline for Innovations on http://www.bomeroup.nl/welcome/innovations/; Dated Feb. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Wayback Machine 2014 Calendar on http://www.bomeroup.nl/welcome/innovations; Date Downloaded Feb. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Final Written Decision 35 U.S.C. § 318(a) and 37 C.F.R. § 42.73 for Case IPR 2016-00594; Dated Aug. 24, 2017. [cited by applicant]
ExifPro image Viewer Home Screen on http://www.exifpro.com/ for case IPR 2017-00476; Downloaded on Feb. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Patents Held on http://www.houwelings.com/files-2/patents.php; Downloaded on Oct. 2, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Horti Daily Worldwide exclusive patents for Houweling's semi-closed greenhouse on http://www.hortidaily.com/print.asp?id=6571; Published on Feb. 19, 2014. [cited by applicant]
Declaration of Alexander Turkewitsch in Support of Patent Owner's Opposition to Petition for Inter Partes Review for Case IPR 2017-00476; Dated Oct. 2, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Videotaped Examination of Merle H. Jensen, PH.D .; Dated Sep. 7, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2026 of European Publication No. EP 1 464 219 A1; Exhibit Dated Sep. 7, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2025 of the Sunergy Greenhouse—One Year of Measurements in a Next Generation Greenhouse; Exhibit dated Sep. 7, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Case IPR 2017-00476 Exhibit 2024 of Using Semi-Closed Greenhouses to Maximize Production while Minimizing Inputs and Waste; Exhibit Dated Sep. 7, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Prosecution of EP Application No. 13184198.3, Extended European Search Report, Jul. 28, 2017. [cited by applicant]
Prosecution of EP Application No. 13184198.3, Exam Report, Jul. 16, 2018. [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
IPR2017-00476, [cited by applicant]
EPO Communication Pursuant to Article 94(3) EPC in counterpart European Patent Application No. EP 07810937.8 dated Nov. 10, 2011. [cited by applicant]
International Search Report and Written Opinion from counterpart application PCT/US2010/001374 mailed Aug. 24, 2010. [cited by applicant]
First Office Action from Mexican Patent Application No. MX/a/2007/008107 dated Dec. 15, 2012. [cited by applicant]
Examination Report for Canadian Patent Application No. 2,592,674, dated Jul. 18, 2012. [cited by applicant]
Second Office Action from Mexican Patent Application No. MX/a/2007/008107 dated Apr. 8, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Intention to Grant from European Patent Appl. No. 07 810 937.8, dated Jun. 10, 2013. [cited by applicant]
Bird & Bird Statement of Defense. Counterclaim and Deed with Exhibits. [cited by applicant]
Kim, et al., “Improving the Distribution of Temperature by a Double Air Duct in the Air-Heated Plastic Greenhouse”, Journal of Bio-Environmental Control 13(3):162-166 (2004). [cited by applicant]
International Preliminary Report on Patentability from PCT/NL2010/000127, dated Mar. 6, 2012. [cited by applicant]
Onderglas, Klimmat/Verwarming, Nummer 12, Dec. 2006. Jaargang 3 Gesolten of semi-gesloten. [cited by applicant]
W.J. Roberts, “Environmental Control of Greenhouses”, Center for controlled Environment Agriculture, Cook College, Rutgers University, Jun. 1997, 19 pages. [cited by applicant]
Schoondereek, J. “Semi-gesloten kas bokst op tegen woestijnklimaat”. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Sep. 6, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Nov. 27, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Apr. 8, 2020. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Jul. 7, 2021. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Sep. 15, 2022. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Jul. 12, 2019. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Oct. 27, 2020. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Feb. 16, 2022. [cited by applicant]
Office Action issued in U.S. Appl. No. 15/990,578 issued Apr. 12, 2023. [cited by applicant]