IP Library Granted Patent US 10,452,694
Granted Patent B2
US 10,452,694 · App. 15/849,212 · Granted Oct 22, 2019

Information extraction from question and answer websites

Inventors: Wei Lwun Lu (San Jose, CA); Denis Savenkov (Atlanta, GA); Amarnag Subramanya (Sunnyvale, CA); Jeffrey Dalton (San Mateo, CA); Evgeniy Gabrilovich (Saratoga, CA); Eugene Agichtein (Atlanta, GA)
Assignee: Google LLC
G06F16/3322G06F17/2705G06F17/2785
View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 10,452,694
App. No.
15/849,212
Granted
Oct 22, 2019
Kind
B2
Abstract

Methods, systems, and apparatus for obtaining a resource, identifying a first portion of text of the resource that is characterized as a question, and a second part of text of the resource that is characterized as an answer to the question, identifying an entity that is referenced by one or more terms of the text that is characterized as the question, a relationship type that is referenced by one or more other terms of the text that is characterized as the question, and an entity that is referenced by the text that is characterized as the answer to the question, and adjusting a score for a relationship of the relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the one or more terms of the text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

Claims (69)

1. A computer-implemented method comprising:

obtaining a resource;

identifying (i) a first portion of text of the resource that is characterized as a question, and (ii) a second portion of text of the resource that is characterized as an answer to the question;

identifying, (i) an entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question, and (ii) an entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

determining, by a machine learned classifier, one or more candidate relationship types that are referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein each of the one or more candidate relationship types is associated with a respective probability, determined by the machine learned classifier, of the candidate relationship type being a proper relationship type between the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

selecting a particular relationship type from among the one or more candidate relationship types based at least on the one or more probabilities; and

adjusting a score associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

2. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , wherein the resource is a question and answer (Q&A) website resource.

3. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

comparing the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the comparison of the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type indicating a match with one or more particular templates.

4. The computer-implemented method of claim 3 , wherein each of the one or more templates is one of a surface-based template or a parser-based template.

5. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

6. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining a parse path from a head token identified from the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein the parse path indicates a syntactic dependency between the head token and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the parse path.

7. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining one or more first terms that are adjacent to one or more terms of the first portion of text that is characterized as the question that reference the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question;

determining one or more second terms that are adjacent to one or more terms of the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question that reference the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the one or more first terms and the one or more second terms.

8. The computer-implemented method of claim 1 , comprising:

aggregating the score associated with the relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question and one or more other scores that are each associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and another entity;

comparing the score associated with the relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question and the one or more other scores that are each associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and another entity; and

establishing, at an entity relationship model and based at least on the comparison, a relationship of the particular relationship type between the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

9. A system comprising:

one or more computers and one or more storage devices storing instructions that are operable, when executed by the one or more computers, to cause the one or more computers to perform operations comprising:

obtaining a resource;

identifying (i) a first portion of text of the resource that is characterized as a question, and (ii) a second portion of text of the resource that is characterized as an answer to the question;

identifying, (i) an entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question, and (ii) an entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

determining, by a machine learned classifier, one or more candidate relationship types that are referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein each of the one or more candidate relationship types is associated with a respective probability, determined by the machine learned classifier, of the candidate relationship type being a proper relationship type between the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

selecting a particular relationship type from among the one or more candidate relationship types based at least on the one or more probabilities; and

adjusting a score associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

10. The system of claim 9 , wherein the resource is a question and answer (Q&A) website resource.

11. The system of claim 9 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

comparing the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the comparison of the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type indicating a match with one or more particular templates.

12. The system of claim 9 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

13. The system of claim 9 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining a parse path from a head token identified from the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein the parse path indicates a syntactic dependency between the head token and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the parse path.

14. The system of claim 9 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining one or more first terms that are adjacent to one or more terms of the first portion of text that is characterized as the question that reference the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question;

determining one or more second terms that are adjacent to one or more terms of the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question that reference the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the one or more first terms and the one or more second terms.

15. The system of claim 9 , wherein the operations comprise:

aggregating the score associated with the relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question and one or more other scores that are each associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and another entity;

comparing the score associated with the relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question and the one or more other scores that are each associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and another entity; and

establishing, at an entity relationship model and based at least on the comparison, a relationship of the particular relationship type between the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

16. A non-transitory computer-readable storage device storing software comprising instructions executable by one or more computers which, upon such execution, cause the one or more computers to perform operations comprising:

obtaining a resource;

identifying (i) a first portion of text of the resource that is characterized as a question, and (ii) a second portion of text of the resource that is characterized as an answer to the question;

identifying, (i) an entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question, and (ii) an entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

determining, by a machine learned classifier, one or more candidate relationship types that are referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein each of the one or more candidate relationship types is associated with a respective probability, determined by the machine learned classifier, of the candidate relationship type being a proper relationship type between the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question;

selecting a particular relationship type from among the one or more candidate relationship types based at least on the one or more probabilities; and

adjusting a score associated with a relationship of the particular relationship type for the entity that is referenced by the first portion of text that is characterized as the question and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

17. The computer-readable storage device of claim 16 , wherein the resource is a question and answer (Q&A) website resource.

18. The computer-readable storage device of claim 16 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

comparing the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the comparison of the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the one or more templates that are each associated with a respective relationship type indicating a match with one or more particular templates.

19. The computer-readable storage device of claim 16 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and an entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question and the entity class corresponding to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question.

20. The computer-readable storage device of claim 16 , wherein determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities comprises:

determining a parse path from a head token identified from the first portion of the text that is characterized as the question to the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question, wherein the parse path indicates a syntactic dependency between the head token and the entity that is referenced by the second portion of the text that is characterized as the answer to the question; and

determining the one or more candidate relationship types and the one or more probabilities based at least on the parse path.

Assignments (2)
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Dec 21, 2017
From: LU, WEI LWUN; SAVENKOV, DENIS; SUBRAMANYA, AMARNAG; DALTON, JEFFREY; GABRILOVICH, EVGENIY; AGICHTEIN, EUGENE
To: GOOGLE INC.
Reel/Frame 044462/0531 →
CHANGE OF NAME Recorded Dec 21, 2017
From: GOOGLE INC.
To: GOOGLE LLC
Reel/Frame 044939/0398 →
Continuity (2)
Continuation 14667792 · Mar 25, 2015
Related Publication 20180150468A1 · May 31, 2018
Cited By (1)
US 12,277,153