IP Library Granted Patent US 12,353,805
Granted Patent B2
US 12,353,805 · App. 18/054,535 · Granted Jul 8, 2025

Adaptive FEM meshing for estimating internal temperature distributions within parts being manufactured via the powder bed fusion process

Inventors: Nathaniel Joseph Wood (Columbus, OH); David John Hoelzle (Columbus, OH)
Assignee: Ohio State Innovation Foundation
G06F30/23B22F10/80B33Y40/00B33Y50/00B22F10/28G06F2113/10G06F2119/08
View Patent ↗
Loading inventors, assignments & file history…
Monitor This Case
Get email alerts when status or documents change.
Order Certified Copies
Most orders are placed with the USPTO same day — all within 24 business hours.
Order via The Patent Place →
Pre-filled with this patent's details
Quick Facts
Patent No.
US 12,353,805
App. No.
18/054,535
Granted
Jul 8, 2025
Kind
B2
Abstract

Estimation algorithms, methods, and systems are provided that estimate the internal temperatures inside of a part being built using a Finite Element Method (FEM)-based thermal model of Powder Bed Fusion (PBF) heat transfer. Closed-loop state estimation is applied to the problem of monitoring temperature fields within parts during the PBF build process. The PBF laser is very small, therefore, so too are the FEM elements nearby the laser. Thus, as the PBF laser moves, a region of high mesh density moves along with it as it progresses over a geometry. In an aspect, regions of high mesh density are predetermined for each time step according to a predefined schedule of laser movements.

Claims (25)

1. A method of estimating the temperature distribution inside a part manufactured by powder bed fusion process, the method comprising:

discretizing the part geometry into finite units to convert a thermal transport model for the part geometry into a set of ordinary differential equations that describes heat transport between elements, the discretizing defining a set of variables that represent temperature at specific spatial locations, using the thermal transport model and thermal properties of the part material as functions in the set of ordinary differential equations;

estimating the values of the variable set using a Kalman filter, using the set of ordinary differential equations, information on heat applied, an estimate of a noise distribution of the process, a measurement of a temperature of the part during the process at specific locations, and an estimate of a noise distribution in the temperature measurement; and

pre-determining adaptive meshes for each time step according to a predefined schedule of laser movements of the power bed fusion process to move a region of high mesh density with the movements of the laser.

2. The method of claim 1 , further comprising:

storing time-varying parameters of the laser;

storing the temperature measurement by every pixel of an infrared (IR) camera that has a moving field of view centered on the laser; and

interpolating the temperature field stored on an adaptive mesh at time step k−1 onto the new mesh at time step k.

3. The method of claim 2 , wherein each adaptive mesh has a target mesh density.

4. The method of claim 2 , further comprising adjusting relative interpolation weights for each node in the adaptive mesh.

5. The method of claim 1 , further comprising using Model Predictive Control (MPC) to alter control inputs to the powder bed fusion process.

6. The method of claim 3 , further comprising mapping a reference temperature onto the adaptive mesh.

7. A system for estimating the temperature distribution inside a part manufactured by powder bed fusion, the system comprising:

a processing module configured to:

discretize the part geometry into finite units to convert a thermal transport model for the part geometry into a set of ordinary differential equations that describes heat transport between elements, the discretizing defining a set of variables that represent temperature at specific spatial locations, using the thermal transport model and thermal properties of the part material as functions in the set of ordinary differential equations;

estimate the values of the variable set using a Kalman filter, using the set of ordinary differential equations, information on heat applied, an estimate of a noise distribution of the process, a measurement of a temperature of the part during the process at specific locations, and an estimate of a noise distribution in the temperature measurement; and

pre-determine adaptive meshes for each time step according to a predefined schedule of laser movements of the power bed fusion process to move a region of high mesh density with the movements of the laser.

8. The system of claim 7 , the processing module further configured to:

store time-varying parameters of the laser;

store the temperature measurement by every pixel of an infrared (IR) camera that has a move field of view centered on the laser; and

interpolate the temperature field stored on an adaptive mesh at time step k−1 onto the new mesh at time step k.

9. The system of claim 8 , wherein each adaptive mesh has a target mesh density.

10. The system of claim 8 , the processing module further configured to adjust relative interpolation weights for each node in the adaptive mesh.

11. The system of claim 7 , the processing module further configured to using Model Predictive Control (MPC) to alter control inputs to the powder bed fusion process.

12. The system of claim 9 , the processing module further configured to map a reference temperature onto the adaptive mesh.

Assignments (2)
ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNOR'S INTEREST Recorded Mar 27, 2025
From: WOOD, NATHANIEL JOSEPH; HOELZLE, DAVID JOHN
To: OHIO STATE INNOVATION FOUNDATION
Reel/Frame 070646/0021 →
CONFIRMATORY LICENSE Recorded Jan 29, 2025
From: OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY
To: NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION
Reel/Frame 070046/0532 →
Continuity (3)
Continuation In Part 17075866 · Oct 21, 2020
Provisional Application 62923753 · Oct 21, 2019
Related Publication 20230078543A1 · Mar 16, 2023
References Cited (51)
US 11498131B2 · Wood · 2022 [cited by examiner]
US 20180304370A1 · Myerberg · 2018 [cited by examiner]
US 20200341062A1 · Wang · 2020 [cited by examiner]
Beckett, Darren, “In-Situ Process Mapping using Thermal Quality Signatures™ during Additive Manufacturing with Titanium Alloy Ti—6Al—4V”, Sigma Labs, Apr. 9, 2018. [cited by applicant]
Bhavar, Valmik, et al. “A review on powder bed fusion technology of metal additive manufacturing.” Additive manufacturing handbook (2017): 251-253. [cited by applicant]
Brandl, Erhard, et al. “Mechanical properties of additive manufactured titanium (Ti—6A1—4V) blocks deposited by a solid-state laser and wire.” Materials & Design 32.10 (Dec. 2011): 4665-4675. [cited by applicant]
Chen, Linear system theory and design, 3rd ed. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 1999. [cited by applicant]
Cverna, Fran, ed. ASM Ready Reference: Thermal properties of metals. ASM International, 2002. [cited by applicant]
DebRoy, Tarasankar, et al. “Additive manufacturing of metallic components-process, structure and properties.” Progress in Materials Science 92 (Mar. 2018): 112-224. (Available online Oct. 7, 2017). [cited by applicant]
Denlinger, Erik R., et al. “Thermal modeling of Inconel 718 processed with powder bed fusion and experimental validation using in situ measurements.” Additive Manufacturing 11 (Jul. 2016): 7-15. [cited by applicant]
Denlinger, Erik R., et al. “Thermomechanical model development and in situ experimental validation of the Laser Powder-Bed Fusion process.” Additive Manufacturing 16 (Aug. 2017): 73-80. [cited by applicant]
Dullerud, et al., A Course in Robust Control Theory. Springer, 2000. [cited by applicant]
Dunbar, A. J., et al. “Development of experimental method for in situ distortion and temperature measurements during the laser powder bed fusion additive manufacturing process.” Additive Manufacturing 12 (Oct. 2016): 25… [cited by applicant]
Evensen, Geir. “The ensemble Kalman filter: Theoretical formulation and practical implementation.” Ocean dynamics 53.4 (2003): 343-367. [cited by applicant]
Franklin, Gene F., J. David Powell, and Michael L. Workman. Digital control of dynamic systems. vol. 3. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley, 1998. [cited by applicant]
Gaikwad, Aniruddha, et al. “Toward the digital twin of additive manufacturing: Integrating thermal simulations, sensing, and analytics to detect process faults.” IISE Transactions 52.11 (Jan. 24, 2020): 1204-1217. [cited by applicant]
Gillijns, Steven, and Bart De Moor. “Unbiased minimum-variance input and state estimation for linear discrete-time systems with direct feedthrough.” Automatica 43.5 (Jan. 2007): 934-937. [cited by applicant]
Gokuldoss, Prashanth Konda, Sri Kolla, and Jürgen Eckert. “Additive manufacturing processes: Selective laser melting, electron beam melting and binder jetting-Selection guidelines.” Materials 10.6 (Apr. 2017): 672. [cited by applicant]
Grasso, Marco, and Bianca Maria Colosimo. “Process defects and in situ monitoring methods in metal powder bed fusion: a review.” Measurement Science and Technology 28.4 (Feb. 2017): 044005. [cited by applicant]
Heigel, J. C., P. Michaleris, and Edward William Reutzel. “Thermo-mechanical model development and validation of directed energy deposition additive manufacturing of Ti—6Al—4V.” Additive manufacturing 5 (Jan. 2015): 9-1… [cited by applicant]
Keist, Jayme S., and Todd A. Palmer. “Role of geometry on properties of additively manufactured Ti—6Al—4V structures fabricated using laser based directed energy deposition.” Materials & Design 106 (Sep. 2016): 482-494. [cited by applicant]
Kolossov, Serguei, et al. “3D FE simulation for temperature evolution in the selective laser sintering process.” International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture 44.2-3 (Feb. 2004): 117-123. [cited by applicant]
Krol, T. A., et al. “Verification of structural simulation results of metal-based additive manufacturing by means of neutron diffraction.” Physics Procedia 41 (Apr. 2013): 849-857. [cited by applicant]
Liu, Yi, and Brian DO Anderson. “Singular perturbation approximation of balanced systems.” International Journal of Control 50.4 (1989): 1379-1405. [cited by applicant]
Marla, Deepak, Upendra V. Bhandarkar, and Suhas S. Joshi. “Models for predicting temperature dependence of material properties of aluminum.” Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 47.10 (Feb. 2014): 105306. [cited by applicant]
Megahed, M., Mindt, HW., Willems, J. et al. LPBF Right the First Time-the Right Mix Between Modeling and Experiments. Integr Mater Manuf Innov 8, 194-216 (Apr. 18, 2019). https://doi.org/10.1007/s40192-019-00133-8. [cited by applicant]
Mower, Todd M., and Michael J. Long. “Mechanical behavior of additive manufactured, powder-bed laser-fused materials.” Materials Science and Engineering: A 651 (Jan. 2016): 198-213. [cited by applicant]
Mukherjee, Tridibesh, and Tarasankar DebRoy. “A digital twin for rapid qualification of 3D printed metallic components.” Applied Materials Today 14 (Mar. 2019): 59-65. (Available online Nov. 17, 2018). [cited by applicant]
Parimi, Lakshmi L., et al. “Microstructural and texture development in direct laser fabricated IN718.” Materials Characterization 89 (Mar. 2014): 102-111. [cited by applicant]
Peng, Hao, et al. “Fast prediction of thermal distortion in metal powder bed fusion additive manufacturing: Part 1, a thermal circuit network model.” Additive Manufacturing 22 (Jun. 20, 2018): 852-868. [cited by applicant]
Peng, Hao, et al. “Fast prediction of thermal distortion in metal powder bed fusion additive manufacturing: Part 2, a quasi-static thermo-mechanical model.” Additive Manufacturing 22 (Aug. 2018): 869-882. [cited by applicant]
Peralta, A. D., et al. “Towards rapid qualification of powder-bed laser additively manufactured parts.” Integrating Materials and Manufacturing Innovation 5.1 (May 5, 2016): 154-176. [cited by applicant]
Peyre, P., et al. “Analytical and numerical modelling of the direct metal deposition laser process.” Journal of Physics D: Applied Physics 41.2 (Jan. 2008): 025403. [cited by applicant]
Plati, A., et al. “Residual stress generation during laser cladding of steel with a particulate metal matrix composite.” Advanced engineering materials 8.7 (Jul. 2006): 619-624. [cited by applicant]
Raghavan, A., et al. “Heat transfer and fluid flow in additive manufacturing.” Journal of Laser Applications 25.5 (Aug. 2013): 052006. [cited by applicant]
Rich, Alan. “Shielding and guarding.” Analog Dialogue 17.1 (1983): 8-13. [cited by applicant]
Ridwan, S., et al. “Automatic layerwise acquisition of thermal and geometric data of the electron beam melting process using infrared thermography.” in Proceedings of the Annual International Solid Freeform Fabrication … [cited by applicant]
Roberts, Ibiye Aseibichin, et al. “A three-dimensional finite element analysis of the temperature field during laser melting of metal powders in additive layer manufacturing.” International Journal of Machine Tools and … [cited by applicant]
Roger, C. R., S. H. Yen, and K. G. Ramanathan. “Temperature variation of total hemispherical emissivity of stainless steel AISI 304.” JOSA 69.10 (1979): 1384-1390. [cited by applicant]
Rombouts, Marleen, et al. “Photopyroelectric measurement of thermal conductivity of metallic powders.” Journal of Applied physics 97.2 (2005): 024905. [Online]. Available: https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1832740. [cited by applicant]
Samar, Raza, et al., “Model reduction with balanced realizations.” International Journal of Control 62.1 (1995): 33-64. [cited by applicant]
Škatarić, Dobrila, and Nada Ratković-Kovaević. “The system order reduction via balancing in view of the method of singular perturbation.” FME Transactions 38.4 (2010): 181-187. [cited by applicant]
Tóth, Roland, et al. “Crucial aspects of zero-order hold LPV state-space system discretization.” IFAC Proceedings vols. 41.2 (Jul. 2008): 4952-4957. [cited by applicant]
Wang, T., et al. “Grain morphology evolution behavior of titanium alloy components during laser melting deposition additive manufacturing.” Journal of Alloys and Compounds 632 (May 2015): 505-513. [cited by applicant]
Wei, H. L., J. W. Elmer, and T. DebRoy. “Origin of grain orientation during solidification of an aluminum alloy.” Acta Materialia 115 (Aug. 2016): 123-131. [cited by applicant]
Wood, Nathaniel, and David Hoelzle. “Temperature states in Powder Bed Fusion additive manufacturing are structurally controllable and observable.” arXiv preprint arXiv:2001.02519 (Jan. 7, 2020). [cited by applicant]
Wood, Nathaniel, and David J. Hoelzle. “On the feasibility of a temperature state observer for powder bed fusion additive manufacturing.” 2018 Annual American Control Conference (ACC). IEEE, Jun. 27-29, 2018. pp. 321-32… [cited by applicant]
Wood, Nathaniel, et al. “Interrogation of mid-build internal temperature distributions within parts being manufactured via the powder bed fusion process.” Proceedings of the 2019 Annual International Solid Freeform Fabr… [cited by applicant]
Touloukian and D. DeWitt, Thermophysical Properties of Matter. IFI/Plenium, 1970, vol. 7, ch. 3, p. 1210. [cited by applicant]
Yadollahi, Aref, et al. “Effects of process time interval and heat treatment on the mechanical and microstructural properties of direct laser deposited 316L stainless steel.” Materials Science and Engineering: A 644 (Se… [cited by applicant]
Yang, Zhuo, et al. “Investigating grey-box modeling for predictive analytics in smart manufacturing.” ASME 2017 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Confere… [cited by applicant]