US 4695343A
· Wycech
· 1987
[cited by applicant]
US 5575526A
· Wycech
· 1996
[cited by applicant]
US 5884960A
· Wycech
· 1999
[cited by applicant]
US 5888600A
· Wycech
· 1999
[cited by applicant]
US 6058673A
· Wycech
· 2000
[cited by applicant]
US 6096403A
· Wycech
· 2000
[cited by applicant]
US 6135542A
· Emmelmann et al.
· 2000
[cited by applicant]
US 6199940B1
· Hopton et al.
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
US 6247287B1
· Takabatake
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
US 6253524B1
· Hopton et al.
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
US 6273496B1
· Guyomard et al.
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
US 6281260B1
· Hanley et al.
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
US 6348513B1
· Hilborn et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6368438B1
· Chang et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6378933B1
· Schoen
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6382635B1
· Fitzgerald
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6412855B1
· Cantineau
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6413611B1
· Roberts et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6467834B1
· Barz et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6471285B1
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6474726B1
· Hanakawa et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6478367B2
· Ishikawa
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 6523884B2
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2003
[cited by applicant]
US 6575526B2
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2003
[cited by applicant]
US 6619727B1
· Barz et al.
· 2003
[cited by applicant]
US 6793274B2
· Riley et al.
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
US 6811864B2
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
US 6817654B2
· Kitagawa et al.
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
US 6890021B2
· Bock et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6896320B2
· Kropfeld
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6908132B2
· Bauhof
· 2005
[cited by examiner]
US 6920693B2
· Hankins et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6921130B2
· Barz et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6932421B2
· Barz
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6935681B2
· Hasler et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6941719B2
· Busseuil et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 6953219B2
· Lutz et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 7025409B2
· Riley et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 7097794B2
· McLeod et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 7105112B2
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 7114763B2
· Riley et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 7125461B2
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 7160491B2
· Barz et al.
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
US 7203620B2
· Li
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
US 7249415B2
· Larsen et al.
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
US 7374219B2
· Brennecke
· 2008
[cited by applicant]
US 7479246B2
· Muteau et al.
· 2009
[cited by applicant]
US 7503620B2
· Brennecke et al.
· 2009
[cited by applicant]
US 7690676B2
· Jaramillo et al.
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
US 7735906B2
· Takahashi et al.
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
US 7748773B2
· Niezur et al.
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
US 7892396B2
· Sheasley
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 7913467B2
· Schneider et al.
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 7997642B2
· Rocheblave et al.
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 8020924B2
· Niezur
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 8029222B2
· Nitsche
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 8047603B2
· Goral
· 2011
[cited by applicant]
US 20020125739A1
· Czaplicki et al.
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
US 20040076831A1
· Hable et al.
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
US 20050035628A1
· Behr et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 20050079779A1
· McLeod et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 20050082111A1
· Weber
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 20050230027A1
· Kassa et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 20050242467A1
· Andre et al.
· 2005
[cited by applicant]
US 20060181089A1
· Andre et al.
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
US 20070018483A1
· Kerscher et al.
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
US 20070212999A1
· Godett
· 2007
[cited by examiner]
US 20080202674A1
· Schneinder et al.
· 2008
[cited by applicant]
US 20080296164A1
· Dajek et al.
· 2008
[cited by applicant]
CN 2311398Y
· 1999
[cited by applicant]
DE 29812843U1
· 1998
[cited by applicant]
DE 202004009473U1
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
DE 102005056460A1
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
DE 102006032867A1
· 2008
[cited by applicant]
DE 102007025930A1
· 2008
[cited by applicant]
EP 0652138A1
· 1995
[cited by applicant]
EP 0995668A1
· 2000
[cited by applicant]
EP 1074457A2
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
EP 1084816A2
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
EP 1354789A2
· 2003
[cited by applicant]
EP 1435320A2
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
EP 1439995B1
· 2004
[cited by applicant]
EP 1495947A2
· 2005
[cited by examiner]
EP 1122155B1
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
EP 1759964A1
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
EP 2154051A1
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
EP 2183150B1
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
EP 2352665B1
· 2014
[cited by applicant]
FR 2749263A1
· 1997
[cited by applicant]
GB 1453426
· 1976
[cited by examiner]
GB 2196584A
· 1988
[cited by examiner]
JP 04252754
· 1992
[cited by applicant]
JP H07237512A
· 1995
[cited by applicant]
JP 09239888A
· 1997
[cited by applicant]
JP H11156977A
· 1999
[cited by applicant]
JP 2001048054A
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
JP 2001322517A
· 2001
[cited by applicant]
WO 99037506A1
· 1999
[cited by applicant]
WO 02068258A1
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
WO 02074608A1
· 2002
[cited by applicant]
WO 2006031761A2
· 2006
[cited by applicant]
WO 2007062757A1
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
WO 2007082677A1
· 2007
[cited by applicant]
WO 2009016106A1
· 2009
[cited by applicant]
WO 2010018190A1
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
WO 2010054194A1
· 2010
[cited by applicant]
Machine translation of DE 102006058601; Jun. 12, 2008; Wohletz et al. (Year: 2008).
[cited by examiner]
Application No. 08162226.8 filed Aug. 12, 2008, (priority document of PCT Patent Application, Application No. PCT/EP2009/060431 filed Aug. 12, 2009; published as WO2010/018190) (D15a in Sika Opposition Proceedings).
[cited by applicant]
Chinese Office Action dated Apr. 19, 2013; Chinese Appln. No. 200980148965.2.
[cited by applicant]
Data sheet for glass fibre reinforced PP; Awp-Rohstoffe; available online at http://www.awp-rohstoffe.de (D7 in Henkel Opposition Proceeding).
[cited by applicant]
Decision rejecting the opposition Application No. 2352665 dated Oct. 31, 2016.
[cited by applicant]
Dubbel, H; Taschenbuch für den Maschinenbau (Handbook of Mechanical Engineering) 17th edition 1990, p. E83; Scringer Verlag; Germany (D3 in Henkel Opposition Proceedings).
[cited by applicant]
International Preliminary Report on Patentability dated Feb. 15, 2011 (Appln. No. PCT/EP2009/060431).
[cited by applicant]
Japanese Office Action dated Oct. 15, 2013; Application No. 2011-535688.
[cited by applicant]
Opposition against patent EP 2352665 (application No. 09752627.1) Dated Jul. 27, 2016.
[cited by applicant]
Opposition to EP2352665; Notice of Opposition by Henkel dated Oct. 2, 2014.
[cited by applicant]
Opposition to EP2352665; Notice of Opposition by Sika dated Jan. 8, 2014.
[cited by applicant]
Pabst, Franz; Kunststoff-Taschenbuch (Plastics manual); 2001; pp. 670-671; Carl Hanser Verlag Munchen Wien; Germany (D2 in Henkel Opposition Proceedings).
[cited by applicant]
PCT Written Opinion of the International Searching Authority dated Oct. 14, 2009 (Appln. No. PCT/EP2009/060431).
[cited by applicant]
Photographs depicting structural reinforcement part of L&L Products, Inc.
[cited by applicant]
Provision of the minutes in accordance with Rule 124(4) EPC, Application No. 2352665 dated Oct. 31, 2016.
[cited by applicant]
Response to Communication of Notices of Opposition filed on May 28, 2015 (EP Appln. No. 09752627.1).
[cited by applicant]
Sika Letter dated Jul. 9, 2015, in German & English translation regarding Opposition to Procedure (EP Appln. No. 09752627.1).
[cited by applicant]
Summons to attend Oral Proceedings Pursuant to Rule 115(1)EPC, Application No. 09752627.1 dated Feb. 17, 2016.
[cited by applicant]
Summons to Attend Preparation for Proceedings Info Concerning Oral Annex to Communication Opposition Dated Feb. 17, 2016.
[cited by applicant]
Translation Opposition by Sika, Application No. 09752627.1 dated Oct. 7, 2014.
[cited by applicant]
Translation Opposition Henkel Application No. 09752627.1 dated Oct. 2, 2014.
[cited by applicant]
Ultimate Tensile Strength dated Sep. 19, 20141 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/utlimate_tensile_stength.
[cited by applicant]
Utility Model Examined Publication No. 49-13208.
[cited by applicant]
Utility Model Unexamined Publication No. 57-121375.
[cited by applicant]
Utility Model Unexamined Publication No. 58-59673.
[cited by applicant]
Rosato et al., Reinforced Plastics Handbook, 3
[cited by applicant]
Grujicic, M., et al., Computational analysis of injection-molding residual-stress development in direct-adhesion polymer-to-metal hybrid body-in-white components,
[cited by applicant]
Lanxess, Plastic/Metal Hybrid Technology, Innovative Design Solutions for Structural Performance with Weight and Cost Reduction, 2005.
[cited by applicant]
Lanxess, Technical Information, Semi-Crystalline Products, Case Study, Body reinforcement using Core products CBS Technology with carriers made of Durethan BKV 35, pp. 1-2, Edition Feb. 3, 2007.
[cited by applicant]
Notice of Opposition against Patent EP2323891 (Application No. EP09806431.4), Mar. 28, 2017.
[cited by applicant]
Communication of the Board of Appeal Pursuant to Article 15(1) of the Rules of Procedure of the Boards of Appeal dated Oct. 29, 2018, Application No. 09752627.1.
[cited by applicant]
Letter dated Apr. 3, 2019, in response to the Communication dated Oct. 29, 2019, Application No. 09752627.1.
[cited by applicant]